20 actors who played the same character as co-star

Marlon Brando and Robert De Niro both earned Oscars for their portrayals of Vito Corleone in Francis Ford Coppola's Godfather trilogy. Decades later, the two Vito Corleones starred together in the 2001 heist thriller The Score, which was directed by the voice of Yoda himself, Frank Oz — an offer they couldn't refuse, he must have made them.

Before both taking on the role of the super fast Quicksilver, Aaron Johnson and Evan Peters played normal, powerless high school students in the DIY superhero action-comedy Kick-Ass (2010). Peters’ American-raised Quicksilver was a major highlight of Bryan Singer’s 1970s-set X-Men sequel/prequel Days of Future Past (2014). While we've only seen glimpses of Johnson’s Quicksilver in action in trailers for Avengers: Age of Ultron, we do know that he will have an Eastern European accent. Other major differences have to do with the shared rights to the character between Fox and Marvel. Marvel can use Quicksilver and his sister Scarlet Witch, but their paternal link to Magneto can’t be mentioned. Also, in the Marvel Cineverse, the characters aren't mutants — you can read the spoilerish origins of their powers here. As for what Johnson thought of Peters' take on the character, he said in an interview: "I didn't watch any of it while making Avengers, but I did see it recently, and it was fantastic."

In the 1997 film Inventing the Abbotts, Jennifer Connelly and Liv Tyler played sisters who are seduced by the same man. They would both go on to be seduced by the same role, that of Elizabeth “Betty” Ross, the love interest of Bruce Banner/Hulk, and the daughter of one of Hulk’s greatest threats, General Thaddeus Ross. Connolly played Ross opposite Eric Bana in Ang Lee’s Hulk (2003). Five years later, Tyler took over the role in The Incredible Hulk, Marvel’s reboot which starred Edward Norton in the title role.

Russell Crowe and Kevin Costner didn’t share any screen time together in Zack Snyder’s gritty Superman reboot, but they played Kal-El/Clark Kent’s biological and adoptive fathers, respectively. Prior to playing Supes' dads in Man of Steel, the two actors had both played Robin Hood. Costner first suited up as the skilled archer who “steals from the rich and gives to the poor” in 1991’s summer romp Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves. Crowe took on the role in 2010 for director Ridley Scott’s Robin Hood, which served somewhat as a prequel to the legendary tale.

Even though Tommy Lee Jones and Josh Brolin have starred in three movies together, they have yet to share any screen time. In 2007, both appeared in the Coen Bros’ neo-Western thriller No Country for Old Men, as well as Paul Haggis’ murder mystery In the Valley of Elah. The parameters of this list dictate that the actors have to play the same character in different movies, but their work opposite Will Smith in Men in Black 3 (2012) technically counts: Jones was merely reprising the role of Agent K from the two previous installments in the franchise and the then-44-year-old Brolin was playing a 29-year-old version of the same character.

When Emma Stone got the call that she had won the role of Peter Parker’s love-interest, Gwen Stacy, in Marc Webb’s reboot of the Spider-Man franchise, she just so happened to be working alongside Bryce Dallas Howard on the movie The Help (2011). Howard had previously played the character in Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man 3. Howard said of Stone, “She's like Gwen Stacy 2.0! Faster, funnier, sexier - like more awesome! She's gonna kill it.” Stone would indeed earn praise for her incarnation of the character in 2012's The Amazing Spider-Man and its 2014 sequel The Amazing Spider-Man 2.

Five years before Anthony Hopkins’ award-winning turn as Hannibal Lecter in The Silence of the Lambs (1991), the cannibalistic doctor was first portrayed by Brian Cox in Manhunter, Michael Mann’s adaptation of Thomas Harris' novel Red Dragon. The film received some critical acclaim but failed to catch on with audiences. The Silence of the Lambs, on the other hand, was a box-office hit and would go on to earn the director, screenwriter, and lead actors Academy Awards. Hopkins reprised the iconic role in the 2001 sequel, Hannibal, and the 2002 prequel, Red Dragon. In 2013, Hopkins and Cox co-starred in RED 2, but apparently the topic of Dr. Lecter never came up during their one day of production together.

In the 1980 Western The Long Riders, real-life siblings Dennis and Randy Quaid played brothers in a gang of bank robbers led by Jesse James. During the ‘90s, the estranged brothers each portrayed the famous gunfighter and dentist John Henry “Doc” Holliday. While the real-life gunslinger passed away when he was only 36 years old, Dennis was 40 years old when he played Holliday in Wyatt Earp (1994), and Randy was 49 years old when he portrayed him in the made-for-TV movie Purgatory (1999).

Look! It’s a bird. It’s a plane. It’s two Lana Langs! Playing the role of Clark Kent’s adoptive mother on the television series Smallville, Annette O’Toole starred alongside Kristen Kreuk, who played Lana Lang, a role O’Toole herself played nearly two decades before in 1983’s Superman III. O’Toole’s Superman III co-stars Christopher Reeve (Clark Kent/Superman) and Margot Kidder (Lois Lane) later made guest appearances on the Superman prequel series, which ran for 10 seasons.

In 1995, Jennifer Grey made a guest appearance on Friends as the former best friend of Jennifer Aniston’s character, Rachel. Years earlier, both Jennifers played Jeanie Bueller — Grey in the 1986 John Hughes classic Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, and Aniston in the short-lived ‘90s sitcom adaptation simply titled Ferris Bueller.