Explore
 Lists  Reviews  Images  Update feed
Categories
MoviesTV ShowsMusicBooksGamesDVDs/Blu-RayPeopleArt & DesignPlacesWeb TV & PodcastsToys & CollectiblesComic Book SeriesBeautyAnimals   View more categories »
Listal logo
Avatar
Added by Onion Jack on 5 Aug 2015 09:00
853 Views 3 Comments
11
vote

Helen, Gene and Peggy - Faces of Charlie Chaplin

Sort by: Showing 18 items
Decade: Rating: List Type:

Role: Servant
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers.
People who added this item 21 Average listal rating (19 ratings) 5.6 IMDB Rating 5.6

Role: Chambermaid
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers.

Role: Spectator
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers.
People who added this item 36 Average listal rating (26 ratings) 5.5 IMDB Rating 5.8

Role: Pretty Patient
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers, another listing for Gene Marsh.
Some sources suggest this is Gene Marsh.

Role: Garlico's Assistant
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers.
People who added this item 24 Average listal rating (19 ratings) 4.6 IMDB Rating 5

Role: Girl in Park
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers.

Role: Actress
Both Helen Carruthers and Gene Marsh are listed on imdb.
People who added this item 31 Average listal rating (24 ratings) 5.8 IMDB Rating 5.9

Role: Nephew's Girlfriend
Listed on imdb as Peggy Page.
Same hat as Helen wore in Recreation?
People who added this item 31 Average listal rating (25 ratings) 6.9 IMDB Rating 6.2

Role: Diner
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers,
a blank entry also appears for Peggy Page.
Are both in this shot? Is there such a thing as both?

Role: Secretary
Listed on imdb as Peggy Page.
People who added this item 28 Average listal rating (22 ratings) 5.8 IMDB Rating 5.4

Role: Landlady
Listed on imdb as Peggy Page.
People who added this item 27 Average listal rating (23 ratings) 6.4 IMDB Rating 5.9

Role: Waitress
Listed on imdb as Peggy Page.
This one does actually look like a different person to those listed as Helen.
People who added this item 26 Average listal rating (22 ratings) 5.9 IMDB Rating 5.6

Role: Spectator with Checkered Coat
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers, another credit for Gene Marsh.
Surely the coat is a clue here.
People who added this item 30 Average listal rating (22 ratings) 6.7 IMDB Rating 5.9

Role: Miss Poor
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers.
People who added this item 25 Average listal rating (20 ratings) 6.2 IMDB Rating 6.2

Role: Clarice
Listed on imdb as Helen Carruthers.
People who added this item 53 Average listal rating (37 ratings) 6.5 IMDB Rating 7

Roles: Maid / Waitress
There are listings on imdb for Helen Carruthers and Gene Marsh.
The BFI website also has a listing for Gene Marsh,
but a DVD note later discredits that information.

Role: Lover in Park
Listed on imdb as both Helen Carruthers and Gene Marsh.
Does this help clear up the mystery?.


It is suggested on one site that this is Gene Marsh,
and that she only appears in this one film...



...and that this is Peggy Page.
Role: Sum-Babee, Lowbrow's Favorite Water Maiden
Listed on imdb as Gene Marsh.

It has also been suggested that Peggy Page was simply a screen name for Helen Carruthers. We tried to work it out, we gave up. Whoever is whoever... one thing is true... lovely!


This is a list of films featuring Charlie Chaplin that also feature either Helen Carruthers, Gene Marsh or Peggy Page. We've done this because people simply can't agree about these three names. Wherever you look, you will find different listings for who plays these roles. Even the BFI offers confused information regarding Tillie's Punctured Romance. All of these films except Dough and Dynamite are listed on the wiki page for Helen Carruthers.

Some say that Peggy Page and Helen Carruthers are one and the same, some say Peggy Page may be a screen name for her sister, some say they are different people. Gene Marsh may have appeared in one film, or as many as... oh I don't know, pick a number.

Anyway, this is a list of films starring someone lovely (except perhaps in the first picture, but we can't expect values from over 100 years ago to have been the same as they are today), enjoy.

Added to

20 votes
The Charlie Chaplin Collection (20 lists)
list by Onion Jack
Published 8 years, 11 months ago 1 comment



Related lists

Happy Birthday! - Charles Chaplin
16 item list by Moon River
17 votes 1 comment
Music...Work of..2pac,Tupac,Makaveli Discog Filmog
52 item list by Dj Levels
14 votes
My Anime List
8 item list by Peter
19 votes 1 comment
Celebrities Who Married Their Co-Stars
93 item list by SwtChaos
16 votes 22 comments
Happy Birthday! - Louis Jourdan
21 item list by Moon River
18 votes 1 comment
life-affirming films
100 item list by Mr. Saturn
57 votes 3 comments
British Comedy: Hi-de-Hi !
33 item list by Holy Godiva
6 votes 1 comment
Syd Chaplin - Faces of Charlie Chaplin
6 item list by Holy Godiva
10 votes 1 comment
The Essential Alec Guinness
26 item list by Kenji
15 votes 3 comments

View more top voted lists

People who voted for this also voted for


More lists from Onion Jack