Added by filmbuilder on 25 Aug 2014 07:29

875 Views 1 Comments

vote

Worst Roger Ebert Reviews

Sort by: Showing 16 items

Decade: Rating: List Type:

1189

4.9

5.7

Babe: Pig in the City (1998)

His consensus: Roger Ebert found 'Babe: Pig In The City' to be more magical than the original 'Babe'. He called it original, delightful and funny.
His rating: 4/4

My consensus: 'Babe: Pig In The City' is a poor film. It's too scary for kids! It also has a boring plot and surprisingly poor visual effects. What age was it written for?
My rating: 1/4

filmbuilder's rating:

2.6

3.1

Barney's Great Adventure (1998)

His consensus: He gives it a thumbs up just because if you like the TV series, you'll also like this.
His rating: 3/4

My consensus: The TV series was bad enough but 76 minutes of Barney's annoying voice and just singing nothing but songs we've heard before and incredibly annoying songs.
My rating: 1/4

filmbuilder's rating:

5231

7.1

7.5

Batman (1989)

His consensus: He highly praised the visual style but criticised the violence.
His rating: 2/4

My consensus: It is violent but it looks great, the action is lots of fun and Jack Nicholson is a good Joker (although Heath Ledger in 'The Dark Knight' is far better)
My rating: 3.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

4468

6.8

7.1

Batman Returns (1992)

His rating: 2/4
My rating: 3.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

1700

5.8

6.5

Bean (1997)

His rating: 2.5/4
My rating: 3.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

2139

6.2

Dark Shadows (2012)

His rating: 2.5/4
My rating: 3.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

597

4.6

5.1

G-Force (2009)

His rating: 2.5/4
My rating: 1/4

filmbuilder's rating:

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix

5718

7.1

7.5

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (2007)

His rating: 2.5/4
My rating: 3.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

1816

4.1

4.4

Home Alone 3 (1997)

His rating: 3/4
My rating: 1.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

3283

5.9

6.4

Honey, I Shrunk the Kids (1989)

His rating: 2/4
My rating: 3.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

1399

5.5

6.2

Johnny English (2003)

His rating: 1.5/4
My rating: 3.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

1674

4.3

4.6

Junior (1994)

His rating: 3.5/4
My rating: 1/4

filmbuilder's rating:

2409

7.1

7.7

South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut (1999)

His rating: 2.5/4
My rating: 4/4

filmbuilder's rating:

8722

6.9

7.4

Spider-Man (2002)

His rating: 2.5/4
My rating: 3.5/4

filmbuilder's rating:

1371

5.9

6.3

Splash (1984)

His rating: 1.5/4
My rating: 3/4

filmbuilder's rating:

1048

6.1

6.4

The Woman In Black

His rating: 3/4
My rating: 1/4

filmbuilder's rating:

Voters of this movie list - View all

Roger Ebert is my all time favourite critic. But I have completely disagreed with some of his reviews! I didn't make this list to trash him but to show when I've completely disagreed with his opinion.