NC:The Top 11 Nostalgia Critic Fuck Part 3
Sort by:
Showing 11 items
Decade:
Rating:
List Type:
Battlefield Earth (2000)
Not realizing the planet Psychlo's air reacts violently with radiation in Battlefield Earth.
Critic mentions how it seems incredibly unlikely that an explosion wouldn’t happen on their planet to set off an atmosphere that was radioactive, especially seeing how violent they were. But actually, the air was a reactive gas, not radiation. Nuclear radiation is what set it off. And the explosion is a nuclear explosion, which Critic guess they’re building up that the Psychlos never came across or tested out.
This fuck-up was referenced in his "Star Trek: Insurrection" review by Linkara.
However, the one thing Critic can't wrap his mind around is how can an advanced violent race not have come up with nuclear fusion and yet somehow, we, the more peaceful planet, came up with nuclear fusion first.
Note: Lewis Lovhaug stated in the "Star Trek: Insurrection" commentary, that although he also despises "Battlefield Earth", he gotten bugged that Doug Walker (Nostalgia Critic) gotten this fact wrong.
Critic mentions how it seems incredibly unlikely that an explosion wouldn’t happen on their planet to set off an atmosphere that was radioactive, especially seeing how violent they were. But actually, the air was a reactive gas, not radiation. Nuclear radiation is what set it off. And the explosion is a nuclear explosion, which Critic guess they’re building up that the Psychlos never came across or tested out.
This fuck-up was referenced in his "Star Trek: Insurrection" review by Linkara.
However, the one thing Critic can't wrap his mind around is how can an advanced violent race not have come up with nuclear fusion and yet somehow, we, the more peaceful planet, came up with nuclear fusion first.
Note: Lewis Lovhaug stated in the "Star Trek: Insurrection" commentary, that although he also despises "Battlefield Earth", he gotten bugged that Doug Walker (Nostalgia Critic) gotten this fact wrong.
moviebuff's rating:

Twilight (2008)
Saying Bella pressured Edward into marrying her when it was vice versa in The Top 11 Dumbasses in Distress, in which he confuses it with her trying to make Edward to turn her into a vampire.
moviebuff's rating:

The Simpsons: Bart's Nightmare - Sega Genesis and Mega Drive
His Let's Play of Bart's Nightmare. Although nothing is factually or technically wrong with it, Critic considers it, along with "Melvin, Brother of the Joker", one of the worst videos he made, feeling that he was too behind the times of the game and many fans got tired of it really fast.
Gordy (1995)
Mistaking a pot for a pan in Gordy.
(NOTE: Although not mentioned in the list, this error was corrected shortly after the episode was uploaded.)
(NOTE: Although not mentioned in the list, this error was corrected shortly after the episode was uploaded.)
moviebuff's rating:

Free Willy (1993)
5. Not knowing that tapping on windows does cause pain for orcas, in which can also lead to death, to which Nostalgia Critic questions why there wasn't a sign about not to tap on the window or why the caretaker wasn't there to stop them.
moviebuff's rating:

Star Trek: Generations (1994)
Not realizing why Soran could not use a ship or shuttle to reach the Nexus in Star Trek: Generations. It was explained briefly, in which Picard wonder why he just can't fly into it and Data states that records show that every ship that tried to approach it was either severely damaged or destroyed. Nostalgia Critic also noted that they are a few other f**ck-ups, in which he cues Linkara to show a link for the Star Trek: Generations Commentary and apologizes for any of the audio issues.
Pee-wee's Playhouse (1986)
In the #1 spot of the Top 11 Mindfucks, Critic called the opening to Pee-wee's Playhouse a mindfuck. He also stated every object from the flowers to the furniture can talk, except for the floor. However, Critic realizes that the floor in the show, name Floory, did talk,
moviebuff's rating:

Reviewing Thomas & The Magic Railroad without ever seeing the show, even though he made it clear he never watched the show growing up and just judging by a move goer. But, he stated if the show sucked despite having never saw it, then he can understand getting angry. He also mention that some people were shocked even though both Alec Baldwin and Peter Fonda, both big named dramatic actors during the time, were in the film while in the show, George Carlin, who became infamous for his album, "Seven Words You Can Never Say on Television" in which he actually said all seven words, was a regular on the show. Despite the fact he was doing "Tarzan II" and "Scary Movie 3".
Patch Adams (1998)
Suggesting that psychiatrists don't attend medical school in Patch Adams when they actually do. Nostalgia Critic stated Patch Adams was better being a psychologist than a doctor. However either way, he still needs to go to medical school to see if the patient's problem is either psychological or physical.
moviebuff's rating:

The mistakes made in his Disneycember reviews.
The ones that were brough up the most:
*The Aristocats - Saying that the Butler will inherit the cats because he hates cats. However, he forgot to mention that not he hates cats, but the cats will get the money first. And once they're out the picture, he will get the inheritance.
*In both "The Rescuers" and "Rescuers Down Under", he stated Miss Bianca is played Zsa Zsa Gabor. However, she was played by her sister, Ava Garbor.
*In "A Goofy Movie", he said that Max's friends are going to a concert of a popular singer, but in fact they're watching it at home. It was Max who said he was going to the concert.
*However, the one that was brought up the most was in "Tarzan", in which he mistakes a leopard for a cheetah.
The ones that were brough up the most:
*The Aristocats - Saying that the Butler will inherit the cats because he hates cats. However, he forgot to mention that not he hates cats, but the cats will get the money first. And once they're out the picture, he will get the inheritance.
*In both "The Rescuers" and "Rescuers Down Under", he stated Miss Bianca is played Zsa Zsa Gabor. However, she was played by her sister, Ava Garbor.
*In "A Goofy Movie", he said that Max's friends are going to a concert of a popular singer, but in fact they're watching it at home. It was Max who said he was going to the concert.
*However, the one that was brought up the most was in "Tarzan", in which he mistakes a leopard for a cheetah.
People who voted for this also voted for
Nostalgia Critic's closing thoughts
best reviews from Nostalgia Critic
Nostalgia Critic Wishlist
Nostalgia Critic: Willy Wonka Vs. Charlie
Nostalgia Critic Wish List
My Top 10 Favorite Teams
Top 11 Nostalgia Critic Episodes (2012)
Top 10 Cartoons de Nickelodeon
Favourite female characters
The Top 11 Nostalgia Critics NC Won't Do
Favorite Nostalgia Critic Reviews
born in year 1982
Nostalgia Critic Wishlist
BAMF's Favorite Youtubers
Nostalgia Critic's closing thoughts
More lists from moviebuff
Total Film's 30 Best Baseball Movies
Total Film's 10 Films We Hope Never Get Sequels
Total Film's 50 Astonishing Movie Mockbusters
Total Film's 50 Worst Comedies
Total Film's 30 Coolest Star Wars Facts
Total Film's 50 '80s Movies Ripe For Remakes
Total Film's Best Movies of the 1980s