First, let me just say that Jane Austen is English mythology, so, I mean, the legalists, sorry the historians, sorry the literary critics, donāt think that this is āaccurateā (you donāt even want to know what angry aristocrat nerds are likeāIām telling you: you donāt), but basically: the character who talks to herself talking to you, who doesnāt notice you replying in nonsense Italian? My mother.Ā
So itās accurate.Ā
I originally thought this was by Joe Wrightāwhoās kinda a sorta interesting literary adaption director, who did a P&P movie, and I searched Netflix for him and came up with this, and didnāt check the credits to make sure before I started watching. But itās ok; I can do a Jane Austen trio instead of a specific director trio, since itās by an unknown girlāso good (girl) but also bad (unknown). So anywayā¦.Ā
āThereās nothing worse than thinking youāve ruined your life, and realizing you have much further to fall.āĀ
So, as I wrote before, (Iām actually editing now! So unlike me!) Jane is one of the most rational and calm-yet-comic writers, and with a decent literary director, it can be fun. It didnāt like, Change My Life, because I knew the bookāit was just easy, but I liked that. But although it is easy to like Jane for whatās not there, even if it is thereāthereās plenty of masked suffering of being around gendered English people, the feminine prick men and the hyper-feminine ill women, but at the same time, I think that, especially in a movie with its visual/physical intelligence, thereās a lot to just ~enjoy, without the whole, drop-dead-for-love thing. (As much as weād all like to, women included, men included.) I donāt know; itās like, just, they have this Nice House, and they visit Wonderful House: you accustom yourself to there being good things in the world, even if people tend to use those good things unwisely. Most stories have a romance plot, but in the King Arthur booksāand I love Arthurian mythology; but in the Arthur books itās like, tribal times; dead men drumming; andāyeah, I mean: anything thatās not abstract like poetry or music involves suffering, but in Nice House stories itās like, ordinary suffering, and extraordinary wealth, whereas in an adventure itās extraordinary suffering, the looming possibility of death, and the ever-present shadow of perversion and scandal, perhaps. And donāt get me wrongāsometimes people need to get a little fucking compassion about not ringing the village church bells and crying perversion, butā¦. I mean, it happens because of unusual unconsciousness, unusualness. Sometimes, all you need, is, either love, or, a story you already know from a longer telling, and just beautyāgardens, mansionsā¦. And a heroine who is also a narrator. Thatās nice. Good movie.Ā
Also, itās funny: I knew this was 2022, but I thought it was Joe Wright, so (and Iām trying not to malign Joe here, although itās funny itās notāitās like, Well, anyway) so I thought that the use of Black talent was a nice touch, in light of the āPanā fiasco, you know. This movie is like, āYouāre welcome to swing by my place anytimeā; that movie was like: So we can spend more time together, Iām going to let you keep living in like 20% of your house. Itās still a nice touch, even if the cleaning up mistakes is less of a, personal, mea culpa?Ā
And, you know, certainly one (very) subtle (Jane-style subtle!) compliment doesnāt erase in peopleās minds another very strongly implied unconscious disrespect, not in the world we live in, rightāand by that, I donāt mean any particular group. But itās a lot more human and open to Black people than Hollywood usually is, and even the rest of the world, as the occasional (numerous, though not by percentages) book or movie on how Black people have usually been treated will attestā¦.Ā
And just that a Black man could end up with a white woman who was the sister of the heroine and not the heroine: the shadow, the whiney little git with nothing on Whitney, you know. And that itās in a fucking Jane Austen mythos, you know.Ā
And if anybody tells you that Anne Elliot looking directly at the screen doesnāt workā¦. I donāt know: have Them make a movie about Their life, lol.Ā
ā¦. āIt angers me that the world denies you the opportunity for a public life. Youād make a great admiral.āĀ
Hey Jude, donāt make it bad. (winks)Ā
ā¦. You always forget that Jane was a Sagittarius, even though it fits like a glove. Jack too. Youād think with all that Pevensie crap that he was a Capricorn, but he wasnāt. That was just the time they lived ināit was before the revolution.Ā
It was a slow revolution, not like the French one, butā¦.Ā
ā¦. Iām glad I watched this though, not only because itās a great story, but because when I read it, in certain parts, I got more the themes than the plot, you know: like the advanced but not the simple, because itās so intricate, sometimes itās easier to see the trees than the forest the way it is in book-formā¦.Ā
ā¦. āJoyāpardon meāIām experiencing joyā¦.āĀ
Now, if he had been looking at the camera: that would have been perfect.Ā
ā¦. Itās like the drama of Black Athena and Psyche, that part of itā¦.Ā
But Iām with cousin Elliot: you can always romance the girl laterā¦. Making sure you inherit the estate, cannot wait. (laughing cat emoji)Ā
ā¦. This was the equal to any of the best Greta Gerwigs: whether āLady Birdā or āLittle Womenā, this is of the same quality.Ā
ā¦. Say not that England has no future.Ā