Login
I've read mixed opinions of this film and was interested in seeing it, so when it was required to be seen as part of a school project, I gave it a go. I don't feel it is as emotionally powerful as it sets out to be. The end is predictable and expected, thus lacking punch. The strengths of the film are the three masterful performances from Clint Eastwood, Hilary Swank and in particular, Morgan Freeman who highly deserved his oscar, in my opinion. But did the film itself deserve best picture? I haven't seen a lot of films from 2004, but it does seem like a weak year. Another criticism would be the inaccuracies that occur during the boxing matches. As far as I am aware, a fighter cannot be hit whilst on the floor, especially not in the face. And yet the film glamorises this on at least two notable occasions. I was surprised that the repertition of the film's main musical riff actually worked and, in it's favour, added a sad spirit to the film's proceedings. Overall then, a mixed bag, but not quite a disappointment, the performances of it's leads alone make it above average.
3/5
