Login
Zack and Miri Make a Porno is one of Kevin Smith's most purely enjoyable and accessible motion pictures to date, a straight-up crude comedy in the vein of The 40-Year-Old Virgin that manages to supplement its humour with heart and depth. It's an ideal project for Smith, calling for his usual modus operandi of profane mischief, unfussy technical specs and a sizable roster of familiar faces. Written and directed by the filmmaker, the film is also firmly in the Smith's comfort zone. Over the years, Smith has repeatedly declined offers to tackle superhero movies and other projects since he knows his limitations. He often does much the same thing in terms of humour and content with his movies, but at least he's good at this stuff.
Sharing an apartment together, do-nothing barista Zack (Seth Rogen) and his long-time school friend Miri (Elizabeth Banks) are destitute, hopelessly behind on their bills and facing homelessness. After their 10-year high school reunion further highlights their lousy circumstances, and after their water, heating and electricity are all shut off, Zack and Miri agree that drastic measures are in order. Desperate to get out of their financial hole, the pair decide to act upon an off-the-cuff idea to make a porno and reap the monetary benefits. Teaming with friends Delaney (Craig Robinson) and Deacon (Jeff Anderson), as well as eager performers Lester (Jason Mewes), Stacey (Katie Morgan) and Bubbles (Traci Lords), they begin production on their porno odyssey, shooting after hours at the local coffee shop where Zack works. Zack and Miri agree to have their first sexual encounter on-camera, but the filming brings out emotions and feelings that the pair never knew they had.
The ultimate narrative trajectory of Zack and Miri Make a Porno is predictable, but, as with all the best comedies, it's more about the journey than the destination. As proved countless times before, Smith has a talent for witty dialogue and entertaining characters, and this remains unchanged here. Zack and Miri Make a Porno is loaded with side-splitting one-liners, hilarious bantering and film references - the characters initially set out to make a Star Wars porno parody called Star Whores, with character names and costumes destined to provoke belly-laughs. As the characters talk, they constantly name-drop websites, movies, actors and other pop-culture stuff, not to mention there's plenty of profanity. Critics have slammed the movie for its excessive language, but Smith is a poet with profane words, and the swearing comes off as a natural part of the characters' vocabulary rather than a gratuitous addition.
With each new film, Smith continues to grow as a filmmaker. He has come a long way since the drably-filmed, amateurish Clerks. - Zack and Miri Make a Porno is visually accomplished, and it's as competent and well-paced as one could reasonably expect from a simple comedy sans big visual effects. Sensitive viewers should tread lightly, as Smith does not baulk from capturing the type of content one would expect from a movie about shooting a porno. Nudity and sex scenes abound, which led to the MPAA slapping the film with an NC-17 rating (not a new experience for Smith). Indeed, the film is just as aggressive as its title. Speaking of the title, it stirred up much controversy, leading to advertisements and even DVD covers shortening the title to Zack and Miri, much to Smith's chagrin. It seems like a strange move to shorten the title as such, since it may fool viewers into believing the film to just be a simple, sweet romantic comedy. Oh boy, that would be a regrettable error. Besides, is the word "porno" really that bad in a world where the Sex and the City movie can be widely advertised?
Smith's best movies are those which are about something, and tackle some sort of life issue. He's also good at telling personal stories that incorporate the writer-director's own experiences (see Chasing Amy). Zack and Miri Make a Porno continues in this vein. The way that the crew make the porno is very much reminiscent of the way Smith produced 1994's Clerks.: shot in the writer-director's place of work at night and produced on the cheap, using hockey sticks for boom poles and only a tiny crew. Smith also probes a sensitive topic: long-time friends becoming romantically involved. The scene depicting Zack and Miri's on-camera sex is one of the director's finest moments; it begins as a hilarious parody of awkward porn situations, but the actual sex is sweet and romantic, even though the characters are on top of a bag of coffee beans. The dramatic aspects of the story do not feel like obligatory rom-com stuff; Smith actually put some emotion and feeling into it, resulting in something fairly mature. The best thing about Zack and Miri Make a Porno, though, is that it still works as entertainment despite its dramatic material.
In the lead roles, Rogen and Banks are marvellously talented and sharp. Rogen just leaned on his usual shtick here, but he's terrific at what he does, espousing charisma and spouting obscenities with confidence. Smith wrote the role of Zack with Rogen in mind, and has stated he would not have made the film if Rogen wasn't interested. Banks, meanwhile, is hugely endearing and beautiful. Rogen and Banks don't exactly share sizzling chemistry, but they're both believable in their respective roles. The supporting cast is fun and colourful, with Robinson and Smith regular Anderson enormously entertaining as the crew of the movie. Jason Mewes (the Jay to Kevin Smith's Silent Bob) is also present here, putting in a playful performance as uninhibited performer Lester. Likewise, real-life porn star Katie Morgan makes a good impression. Added to this, Justin Long and Brandon Routh show up in cameo roles, and their work is hilariously shameless.
If you're in the right mindset, Zack and Miri Make a Porno is a perfect time-waster, enjoyable and thoughtful. It's perhaps one of Smith's less daring filmmaking endeavours, as it essentially uses the When Harry Met Sally formula...except it involves making a dirty movie. Plus, the film not as mature or insightful as Smith's Chasing Amy. Nevertheless, Zack and Miri Make a Porno is good fun, and it's hard to imagine Smith's fanbase being dissatisfied with it.
7.8/10
