LoginSuggestion: 'Add Comment' modification to new lists
VIP Moderator
Prelude
17 years, 3 months ago at Jan 15 14:13 - I love the new 'ADD NOTE' option that list creators have, but would it be much work to allow everyone that views a list to 'ADD COMMENT' to each entry, with list creator still having option to delete those comments if it doesnt add to their list. Right now, there is just a general comment at end of list.
Take this list for example:
www.listal.com/list/most-controversial-games
Thilian added a comment about Doom controversy, but it would be much nicer if it got ammended/added right below my description for that entry, similar to how blogs or other dynamic site handle comments.
you could still leave comment at bottom for GENERAL comments to the list.
Take this list for example:
www.listal.com/list/most-controversial-games
Thilian added a comment about Doom controversy, but it would be much nicer if it got ammended/added right below my description for that entry, similar to how blogs or other dynamic site handle comments.
you could still leave comment at bottom for GENERAL comments to the list.
VIP Moderator Prelude
17 years, 3 months ago at Jan 15 14:16 - In the meantime, as list creator, I guess it could also be achieved manually by adding his comment to my entry for DOOM, and deleting his comment at bottom of the list. so yeah, its a suggestion, but backburner suggestion (unless its a real easy fix).
Really, there's so few comments to any of the lists that the more I think of it, the more back back back burner this suggestion should go, unless we get a sudden massive increase in list commenting.
Really, there's so few comments to any of the lists that the more I think of it, the more back back back burner this suggestion should go, unless we get a sudden massive increase in list commenting.
Deleted user
Deleted
17 years, 3 months ago at Jan 15 19:41 - If I'd made my comment on the actual DOOM game, it'd look nicer if it were indented like comments on Youtube. The aesthetics should be on-key. Sing365 has an artist page with Artist comments and Song comments below the bio summary and list of songs. Clicking on the bio gives the whole thing plus all Artist comments. Clicking on a song gives the lyrics plus all Song comments.
Deleted user
Deleted
17 years, 3 months ago at Jan 16 16:30 - Is this the official LISTS suggestion thread?
1) Auto-rearrange based on date, alphabet, system, user ratings, and any other little thing that'd just come in handy.
2) One-click means of adding an item to the list. When it shows up you have to drag it - clicking takes you to the item page. If you could click! and it'd automatically appear at the bottom of the list, that'd be great! Or maybe even having a tool bar for each specific list item with those kinds of options would work.
3) Alternate means of adding to list based on different aesthetics, as in indicating which number something will show up while scrolling up and down through names only, like on DVD Aficionado or iLike.
1) Auto-rearrange based on date, alphabet, system, user ratings, and any other little thing that'd just come in handy.
2) One-click means of adding an item to the list. When it shows up you have to drag it - clicking takes you to the item page. If you could click! and it'd automatically appear at the bottom of the list, that'd be great! Or maybe even having a tool bar for each specific list item with those kinds of options would work.
3) Alternate means of adding to list based on different aesthetics, as in indicating which number something will show up while scrolling up and down through names only, like on DVD Aficionado or iLike.
Deleted user
Deleted
17 years, 3 months ago at Jan 17 15:50 - How about moving the comments to the right side of the list, under the list description? I think this would work better for long lists with 100+ items, rather than having comments WAY DOWN at the bottom.
Not sure about comments for each item, because it really depends on the list whether it's useful or not.
Just as long as only the list-maker has the right to rearrange his list. I think that item order should be fixed to those viewing the list, as the list-maker has every right to decide exactly how his list looks like.
Not sure about comments for each item, because it really depends on the list whether it's useful or not.
Auto-rearrange based on date, alphabet, system, user ratings, and any other little thing that'd just come in handy.
Just as long as only the list-maker has the right to rearrange his list. I think that item order should be fixed to those viewing the list, as the list-maker has every right to decide exactly how his list looks like.
Deleted user
Deleted
17 years, 3 months ago at Jan 17 21:58 - If the title of the item could be specified as a Comment Title of sorts, that'd fix the differentiation. If a link at the top for 'Skip to Comments' were added that scrolls you down just enough, that'd fix the inconvenience.
I agree. It also encourages good organizational skills and knowledge of what the whoozit you're talking about when you make a list. You can probably fix incorrect product information based on how things are auto-sorted.
Just as long as only the list-maker has the right to rearrange his list. I think that item order should be fixed to those viewing the list, as the list-maker has every right to decide exactly how his list looks like.
I agree. It also encourages good organizational skills and knowledge of what the whoozit you're talking about when you make a list. You can probably fix incorrect product information based on how things are auto-sorted.