Explore
 Lists  Reviews  Images  Update feed
Categories
MoviesTV ShowsMusicBooksGamesDVDs/Blu-RayPeopleArt & DesignPlacesWeb TV & PodcastsToys & CollectiblesComic Book SeriesBeautyAnimals   View more categories »
Listal logo

Query: short "reviews"

DefenderOfKnowledge 18 years ago at Apr 21 1:22 -
Just wondering what to do about short "reviews" such as this one.

www.listal.com/viewentry/13768/#commentpost

Another thing is that it would be semi nice to see the name of the review without having to click "Reply to this entry". I know it shows the name on profiles and stuff but still. If not, that's ok. I'm sure Tom is busy. Just something to consider.

But the short reviews is really getting annoying. And by "short" I mean like, not really a review. Like the topic of that review is "umm this one is awesome". I dunno, not much of a review....
VIP
Moderator
Prelude 18 years ago at Apr 21 3:02 -
also, very long reviews are a problem

www.listal.com/reviews/tv/1/all

see how far down you have to go past all those episode wrapups of Battlestar Gallactica before you see another review.

truncating them, and click 'more' to see the rest, is needed.
DefenderOfKnowledge 18 years ago at Apr 21 3:33 -
Oh my gosh! I thought some of my reviews were a tad long!!!!! Those are a real nuisance. We should translate it and see if it's actually anything about the show.
tartan_skirt 18 years ago at Apr 21 13:19 -
I brought up the possible more/less feature a while ago, but my topic has disapeared back a few pages at the moment. :P Anyway, here was what I said:

www.listal.com/groups/viewthread/1182/

I really don't like the exceedingly short reviews either. Giving people points for things like that just doesn't seem good. It's an issue that keeps coming up around here but nothing official is ever said about it...
DefenderOfKnowledge 18 years ago at Apr 24 0:31 -
Here's another suggestion: remove videos that have nothing to do with the topic they are posted under.

www.listal.com/person/tom-kenny