LoginExplore reviews
Moderator Admin
Tom
16 years, 11 months ago at Jun 6 23:13 - I've added a new explore reviews page
www.listal.com/reviews
This similar to the recent explore lists page
www.listal.com/lists
www.listal.com/reviews
This similar to the recent explore lists page
www.listal.com/lists
Deleted user
Deleted
16 years, 11 months ago at Jun 7 10:44 - Fantastic!
Just once mistake - Under top Reviewers it still has 'List based on 2 items and 1 vote'.
Just once mistake - Under top Reviewers it still has 'List based on 2 items and 1 vote'.
Moderator
Seaworth
16 years, 11 months ago at Jun 8 13:25 - Now I'm not the type of guy to rain on anyones parade but I note a certain amount of CORRUPTION in the Top 'Review Writer'.
His Music reviews are song lists for the album (which I suppose is helpful but doesn't tell us anything critical or interesting about the album whcih we should be presented with a review). Not too mention his DVD reviews which are single sentences.
The biggest crime is that ALL his reviews have 1/2 votes despite being absolutely useless. Once again, can there be a rule for double accounts?
There is no point people voting if one person can vote for their own stuff by signing into their Alt account. THIS IS MADNESS!!
His Music reviews are song lists for the album (which I suppose is helpful but doesn't tell us anything critical or interesting about the album whcih we should be presented with a review). Not too mention his DVD reviews which are single sentences.
The biggest crime is that ALL his reviews have 1/2 votes despite being absolutely useless. Once again, can there be a rule for double accounts?
There is no point people voting if one person can vote for their own stuff by signing into their Alt account. THIS IS MADNESS!!
PvtCaboose91
16 years, 11 months ago at Jun 8 14:03 - Here here Gunza Blazin. I cannot believe the top reviewer just has music track lists and stuff...just madness!
I wonder if he does have double accounts...
Well spotted buddy. I was thinking the same thing about an hour ago!
I wonder if he does have double accounts...
Well spotted buddy. I was thinking the same thing about an hour ago!
Moderator Admin Tom
16 years, 11 months ago at Jun 8 16:19 - When I add the ability to edit tracklistings I will transfer them and remove the reviews.
Moderator Admin Tom
16 years, 10 months ago at Jun 10 16:03 - I will have to add in a check to not promote a review if a review from the same user has already been promoted in a certain time frame to avoid single users dominating the page (as happened recently)
Deleted user
Deleted
16 years, 10 months ago at Jun 10 16:05 - I concur!
How about having a 'featured review' in one of the corners - a review, maybe generated at random, that has at least 2 votes and x amount of words?
How about having a 'featured review' in one of the corners - a review, maybe generated at random, that has at least 2 votes and x amount of words?
Deleted user
Deleted
16 years, 10 months ago at Jun 10 17:45 - Good idea GA, although 2 votes might not be enough, iv seen relatively slack reviews get more. Maybe 4-5 votes?
VIP Moderator
Prelude
16 years, 10 months ago at Jun 11 2:24 - I can't believe my NeverEnding Story III is top rated review.
LOL
um, thanks? I'm actually a bit embarrassed by the bashing (i wouldnt call it a review) but 9 votes, right on :)
LOL
um, thanks? I'm actually a bit embarrassed by the bashing (i wouldnt call it a review) but 9 votes, right on :)
Deleted user
Deleted
16 years, 10 months ago at Jun 11 9:54 - It's pretty embarrassing that it's joint top rated. Dark days indeed for listal!
I'm glad this page is here giving exposure to some of the other reviews on listal.
I'm glad this page is here giving exposure to some of the other reviews on listal.
PvtCaboose91
16 years, 10 months ago at Jun 11 13:11 - Oh wow...I'm actually included in the top reviewers. *blushing*
I feel so accepted! Lol.
I feel so accepted! Lol.
Deleted user
Deleted
16 years, 10 months ago at Jun 11 13:41 - will have to add in a check to not promote a review if a review from the same user has already been promoted in a certain time frame to avoid single users dominating the page (as happened recently)
Or maybe limit the number of reviews on that page per user. i.e. Each user can only have two or three reviews displayed in that area...
That might help vary it up as every time I look, there seems to be about 15 reviews from the same person, and then a handful of others. It would be nice to help encourage other users and their reviews.