Soldier Reviews

Sergeant Todd (Kurt Russell) is a hardened soldier trained from birth, indoctrinated as a killing machine who carries out orders without a second thought. Every emotion has been leeched out of him after decades of fighting in various wars and campaigns. However, the ambitious Colonel Mekum (Jason Isaacs) introduces a new breed of genetically engineered soldiers that are younger, faster, stronger and better than their predecessors, rendering Todd and his comrades obsolete. Discarded after being bested by Mekum's finest soldier, Todd is dumped on a planet inhabited by a small band of stranded colonists. Although Todd is accepted into their community, trouble looms when Mekum arrives on the planet to put his new soldiers through a training exercise. He deems the colonists' presence unlawful and orders their termination, but Todd is unwilling to let that happen.

To the credit of Peoples and Anderson, Soldier takes its time building the characters and observing Todd as he struggles to ingratiate himself into a more peaceful culture. Peoples' script has several things on its mind, exploring if a lifelong killing machine can assimilate themselves back into society. It doesn't exactly explore the concept with any real depth, but it gives what's essentially a dumb action film some thematic relevance. However, the narrative here plays out like any generic "new guy moves into town and saves the townspeople" flick (Shane, anyone?), and it doesn't contain many original elements. As a matter of fact, it borrows from any number of films, including Aliens and Rambo. Also problematic: Mekum's motivation for heading to the planet to decimate the populace is completely flimsy, leaving us to just shrug and accept the contrived behaviour.

Anderson gets a lot of hate for his movies, but he knows how to construct fluid and exciting action scenes. The fight choreography here is solid, and the gun battles are badass. When Todd cuts loose and sets out to eliminate his opponents, Soldier is insanely entertaining, guaranteed to leave you with a big dumb grin on your face. It's the type of red-blooded American action film we often saw back in the '80s when the "one-man army" genre was so prominent (Rambo 2, Commando). The production values here are also impressive, as expected from a well-budgeted $60 million film. Although a few special effect shots look dated (especially an explosion at the end), this only amplifies the fun factor. If you come to Soldier seeking an evening of pure popcorn entertainment, rest assured that it delivers in a big way. It's definitely cheesy, but that's all part of the picture's charm. They don't make enjoyably goofy flicks like this anymore.

Russell was handed a challenging task in portraying Todd. Although the star is on-screen practically all the time, he only says about 100 words throughout the entire movie. Instead of using words to convey his character's feelings, Russell had to do all the heavy lifting with facial expressions and body language. And he pulls it off beautifully. It's a terrifically nuanced performance, showing that Russell is a better actor than he gets credit for. Also in the cast is Isaacs, who essentially plays a cartoonish, moustache-twirling villain. It's a cheesy role, but Isaacs seems in the right spirit. Gary Busey is also here, showing us why every movie can benefit from a touch of Busey.

With a few rewrites, Soldier could've been a thoughtful sci-fi action masterpiece. As it stands, this is just a ridiculously entertaining blockbuster overseen by a veteran purveyor of filmic junk food. Unfortunately, the film was a box office disaster, grossing less than $15 million at the domestic box office and predominantly going straight-to-video in the rest of the world. The critics used it as a punching bag, as well. But it matters not. As long as you can accept the movie for what it is, it's a blast.

7.1/10

To be honest, I had some rather low expectations concerning this flick but since I have a weak spot for Kurt Russell, I thought I should give it a try anyway. Well, eventually, it was honestly not really good, I’m afraid. Indeed, even though the whole thing had some potential, it was pretty much just a glorified B movie and, to really enjoy it, you shouldn't take it too seriously. I guess the main issue for me is that I'm not a huge fan of such B pictures... I have to admit it, there were some good action scenes and Kurt Russel was pretty good but the story and the movie remained pretty average. At the end of the day, it was a rather typical effort from Paul W.S. Anderson who is specialized in such average stuff. Honestly, I felt pretty bad for Kurt Russell as he worked out three or four hours a day for eighteen months to get himself into the "pumped-up" condition we see in this film. I mean, he was all right but the plot was just so tedious. Still, if you are fan of this genre, you may end up enjoying it more than I did otherwise you should probably watch something else.