Loginindividual TV episode
Chuck Kahn
17 years, 8 months ago at Oct 8 13:57 - In future, will listal be able to accept individual TV episodes? It would be handy to be able to rate and mark individual episodes as watched.
Cannot add tv episodes
You tried to add an imdb page which was for a individual TV episode, we can only accept pages for tv series.
Please try again with the page for the actual series.
Moderator Admin
Tom
17 years, 8 months ago at Oct 9 20:51 - Yes I would like to add it but I will need a way of letting people add episode information.
Chuck Kahn
17 years, 2 months ago at Apr 20 15:05 - Is there another site that does this? (Creates a watched list of individual TV episodes?)
Moderator
Seaworth
17 years, 2 months ago at Apr 20 15:10 - Look at Chuck. He can't wait to leave Listal.
A few of us discussed this before in another thread. Mainly about reviewing individual episodes. I, aswell as a few others, felt it wasn't worth it. There is only so much you can say about an episode without it turning into a synopsis.
If you check Battlestar Galactica, some guy there has taken liberties with writing synopsis' as opposed to reviews (about 20 of them!). I think reviewing seasons is a good addition but not episodes. That is all I have to say.
A few of us discussed this before in another thread. Mainly about reviewing individual episodes. I, aswell as a few others, felt it wasn't worth it. There is only so much you can say about an episode without it turning into a synopsis.
If you check Battlestar Galactica, some guy there has taken liberties with writing synopsis' as opposed to reviews (about 20 of them!). I think reviewing seasons is a good addition but not episodes. That is all I have to say.
Manling
17 years, 2 months ago at Apr 20 18:21 - I would be happy with the rating of individual seasons. I think that is a little more practical than rating individual episodes.
Devious Phenomenon
17 years, 2 months ago at Apr 20 20:04 - Agreed TA, rating and reviewing and listing episodes would be pure chaos... Seasons would be fine though, after all most shows don't have... too many seasons lol
Deleted user
Deleted
17 years, 2 months ago at Apr 20 20:58 - Seasons can be reviewed already using the DVD function dont forget! I agree that individual episodes would be a bit rediculous though, however i always wanted to know about individual Songs so i guess im a hypocrite! The reason individual songs would be better IMO is that sometimes you can absolutely hate a band/album etc and not want to review it/them but you might love/hate one particular song which you'd like to write about etc. It would be a good function for keeping track of discographies.
I have gone off topic a bit here, but in conclusion i think we already have a season rating means, and you can always write in your review of that season your favorite and least favorite episodes.
I have gone off topic a bit here, but in conclusion i think we already have a season rating means, and you can always write in your review of that season your favorite and least favorite episodes.
Devious Phenomenon
17 years, 2 months ago at Apr 20 21:37 - the song idea would prove useful, I hate quite a few bands but they have just ONE song that I LOVE
Chuck Kahn
16 years ago at Jun 27 13:51 - Seasons are not homogeneous in quality -- some episodes rate higher than others -- giving a season a single rating doesn't provide as much illumination in this regards. Also, having an episode listing would be useful as a checklist of episodes seen versus episodes unseen. Sometimes one loses track of where you are in a series and a checklist would be a quick way of figuring out which eps need watching. (I could really use this for Family Guy -- the season structure for that show is confusing.) This site is all about lists, so I don't see the need for discouragement with regards to Listal living up to its name -- just don't use the episode rating if you don't want it.
Chuck Kahn
15 years, 8 months ago at Oct 28 13:36 - I found a workaround -- list movies I've seen on listal, then list tv episodes I've seen on imdb, then combine the two feeds with friendfeed:
friendfeed.com/search?q=listal.com+OR+imdb+from%3Achuckkahn
friendfeed.com/search?q=listal.com+OR+imdb+from%3Achuckkahn