Explore
 Lists  Reviews  Images  Update feed
Categories
MoviesTV ShowsMusicBooksGamesDVDs/Blu-RayPeopleArt & DesignPlacesWeb TV & PodcastsToys & CollectiblesComic Book SeriesBeautyAnimals   View more categories »
Listal logo
Avatar
Added by PvtCaboose91 on 10 Dec 2012 12:02
1394 Views No comments
4
vote

A Christmas Carol: Best to Worst

Sort by: Showing 9 items
Decade: Rating: List Type:


Pros:
- George C. Scott is an incredible Scrooge
- The film takes the source material as a mere guideline, and the writer adds his own unique voice to the material, changing things, making the dry dialogue more digestible and adding a few extra things
- It was shot in an actual town, which makes the setting feel really authentic as opposed to the soundstages and backlots of other versions
- Flavoursome score

Cons:
- Feels like a made-for-TV production, as there's not a great deal of flair in the camera angles. Could have done with a bit more polish
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom


Pros:
- It's a wonderful way to introduce this story to kids. They will find all other versions to be dismally boring, but this one is told by the Muppets, which lightens the tone and atmosphere. It's delightful. And it delivers the messages the story is renowned for in an effective fashion
- Michael Caine makes for a great Scrooge here
- The use of the Muppet characters is absolutely masterful
- It gives the material a new spin and makes it feel fresh again
- Music is awesome

Cons:
- Nothing, really. The story has just been done to death, so the film feels a bit predictable
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom
People who added this item 948 Average listal rating (629 ratings) 6.5 IMDB Rating 7


Pros:
- It's a fresh modern take on the story. It's not afraid to do something daring and creative with the stale source material, but it's also respectful of the Dickens text
- Billy Murray is God
- It's funny as hell, full of one-liners
- It's still relevant over two decades later

Cons:
- The PG-13 rating seems to neuter some of the humour. Could've been funnier as a profane R-rated comedy
- Could have been faster paced
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom


Pros:
- It packs a lot into a brisk running time, and is therefore never boring and never stops moving
- Alistair Sim is back as Scrooge and is as good as ever
- Sumptuous animation
- Unrelentingly dark, like this ghost story should be

Cons:
- Bit too short. Could've done with another 5 minutes of content
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom
People who added this item 149 Average listal rating (95 ratings) 7.6 IMDB Rating 8.1


Pros:
- Alistair Sim is a very good Scrooge
- It's well-made and the dramatic scenes still pack a punch
- Scrooge's arc feels genuine and organic

Cons:
- At times it's too stilted
- Some scenes look like they were filmed on backlots and sound stages
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom


Pros:
- Dramatic scenes remains very effective
- Great cast from top to bottom. Reginald Owen makes for a highly effective Scrooge
- Has its own unique voice because it makes a number of changes to the source material which really do work
- It's surprisingly accessible and nimble

Cons:
- Too underdone. Rushes through the material a bit too excessively
- Ghostly elements aren't as spooky as they should be
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom


Pros:
- Animation is amazing. Highly detailed and smooth. The opening shot taking us through London is especially impressive. Plus, the 3D is highly effective.
- Jim Carrey does a fairly impressive job playing so many parts
- Really takes off from time to time

Cons:
- Few things really cheapen the experience, including awful slapstick and unbelievable action scenes. Scrooge is a stuntman?
- Dialogue needed to be changed. It's far too dry
- Fails to do anything daring with the source material
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom


Pros:
- Patrick Stewart is surprisingly good as Scrooge
- It's a well-made production

Cons:
- It's too by-the-numbers. There's nothing new here.
PvtCaboose91's rating:
Rate:
Watched Wanted Custom

I think Charles Dickens' 1843 novella A Christmas Carol is the most adapted literary source ever. There are fucking hundreds of adaptations out there. Here are the versions I've seen, ranked from best to worst.

Added to




Related lists

A Christmas Carol (1989)
16 item list by darthjoker12
1 votes
Films based on Christmas - best to worst.
26 item list by SJMJ91
7 votes
Best Alternative Christmas TV & Movies
19 item list by PhineasPoe
11 votes
Dreamcasting Twisted: A Haunted Carol: The Movie
12 item list by 186FleetStreet
3 votes
A Christmas Carol Dream Cast
13 item list by darthjoker12
2 votes
2013 Films: Best to Worst
36 item list by OsamaExKing
17 votes 1 comment
Worst Horror Films of 2011
10 item list by Dan
73 votes 14 comments
Best Horror Films of 2011
10 item list by Dan
37 votes 5 comments
Movies of 1992
29 item list by nathan
Worst Christmas Movies In History
16 item list by PvtCaboose91
73 votes 32 comments

View more top voted lists

People who voted for this also voted for


More lists from PvtCaboose91