Join Listal here 
Existing members 
Login here 
Join Listal to create lists, share images, get recommendations and much more


Choose file... or enter url:
I should start by saying that I normally hate black and white films, they really annoy me. I think it's because colours really show emotions and give films more character, I just find it more interesting. But in this case I survived watching this whole film, and came to realise that the black and white made this movie more.. mysterious. It was probably the better choice than making this in colour, it gave me an idea of the film when it had only just started. It's unique, mysterious, strange, humorous and unlike any other film I have seen before.

It's definitely something strange from Billy Bob Thornton, it's nothing at all like any of his other films. Obviously it's not a comedy, though it does have a few jokes, so it's nothing like his new comedy movies. And even some of the drama ones I have seen before of his.. it was like another actor. That, by the way, isn't a bad thing. It's a great thing, I love the way he can go from films like Sling Blade, to this, to Bad Santa. He has a huge range of characters he can play so well, and they're all so different. In this movie Billy Bob is Ed Crane, very mysterious and somehow seemed to be the normal, boring kind of guy. We are shown important parts of his life before and after an incident that would change his whole life.

Apart from Billy Bob Thornton, this movie also had some great stars. Scarlett Johansson was great as her role of a young girl who Ed finds an important part of his life, and is determined to make sure her life isn't as much of a disaster as his. Tony Shalhoub was also quite good in this film, there wasn't much to his character but he mastered him and made the movie a lot more entertaining to watch.

This is definitely worth seeing if you are a Billy Bob Thornton fan, it's complex at times, but definitely a beautifully made film. The movie climax at the end was done exceptionally well and the feeling still stayed with me after the credits. "I don't know what waits for me, beyond the earth and sky. But I'm not afraid to go."

Added by Claudia 6 years ago
on 16 December 2007 02:53

People who voted for this also voted for


Posted: 1 year, 11 months ago at Aug 9 15:19
'I should start by saying that I normally hate black and white films, they really annoy me'

Just after this sentence, you already lost all credibility... Do you know how many amazing black and white masterpieces you will miss? Too bad for you...
Posted: 1 year, 11 months ago at Aug 9 18:09
I agree with Monsieur LeFourbe.
Posted: 7 months, 1 week ago at Dec 21 0:27
Exactly in what way do black and white films not accurately convey emotions? If anything, they often expose much deeper and more pure emotions in the films. They often convey a sense of depression (i.e. Satantango, The Last Picture Show, Raging Bull, The Elephant Man, etc.), rather than how a color film can only actualize visual remarkableness (and I am not in no way discrediting black and white films from this categorization, nor am I completely discrediting color films from being unable to convey cinematic emotion). The black and white films I mentioned earlier all probably had the option of being shot in color and took advantage of the alienation or depression the medium conveys. Older black and white films didn't do this as often because there was no real color back then and black and white was much more "pure" or even technicolor may have not been around back then, but still; look at The Passion of Joan of Arc or Greed; with color they would suck.

You have no claim to say what you did in the opening; it is an immature, idiotic allegation that only an immature and idiotic person would ever even consider to say, unless it was purely sarcastic. So, Fuck You.

Oh, and did you vote for your own review somehow? Your pic is there and when I clicked on it your exact profile appeared before me; what sort of witchcraft have you been pulling, Devil?!

Login or Signup to post a comment