Join Listal here 
Existing members 
Login here 
Join Listal to create lists, share images, get recommendations and much more
Forum home > TV Shows

A Genuine Lost Discussion (SPOILERS)

Moderator
Rank : 34
Posted : 6 years, 4 months ago at Mar 24 21:49 -
So who is still watching it?

Seeing as Season 4 has a month break, we might aswell kick up some dust and see where everyone thinks its all going. Facts:
-Season 4 still has 5 Episodes to go.
-The Oceanic 6 have all been revealed: Jack, Kate, Hurley, Sayid, Aaron and Sun.

Some questions:
-Whose faction would you be on? Jack's or Locke's?
-Can Ben be trusted?
-Is everyone in as much danger as they think?
-Who are the genuine 'Good Guys'?
-Apart from being a safe haven, what is the Temple?
-Would you kick Michael in?

Let 'er rip.
Deleted user
Posted : 6 years, 4 months ago at Mar 24 22:04 -
I would be on Lockes side right now, he seems more interested in figuring out the Island, staying alive, doing what seems right etc. Jack is just interested in being a shmuck and getting home. It seems all my favorites have gone with Locke, or gone to the Boat, everyone else is with Jack!!

Ben will turn out to be the good guy in my opinion, he can be trusted because they have no choice he is right thats all that is to it.

I think the danger is typical Lost drama, so there will not be any real danger just fear.

The genuine good guys are only going to be our guys, the plane folk + Desmond and possibly Ben. I think any one else is going to be pretty evil.

I reckon the temple will actually be a temple! Ie something to do with the big foot that we saw, itl give us more info about the island religion and perhaps Jacob?

Id give Michael a bit of a kick in, but then i would welcome him back into the group, he aint the worst character on Lost, and he could wind up being quite interesting.

---------------

Anyone got any ideas about the smoke monster? Jacob? Jacks Dad?
Who was in the coffin?

Moderator
Rank : 81
Posted : 6 years, 4 months ago at Mar 24 22:10 -
Ben's the only thing keeping the series alive.. I recon he's a bad guy. The only real good guy is Desmond, and there isnt enough Sawyer in it anymore!!

Also I think Sayid was a bit of a bastered for handing over Michael like that...even though I would give him a kick for WAAAAALT!
Moderator
Rank : 34
Posted : 6 years, 4 months ago at Mar 24 22:20 -
I reckon Sayid did it intentionally because he knew Michael couldn't be killed as evident by his story. Considering he went through the Desmond ordeal, he is more than likely to believe the 'strange happenings' of his story.

Michael had no reason to lie since he came all the way back, seeking redemption.

As for the coffin, I think it is either Sayid or Michael. For various reasons, that I'll delve into later.
Deleted user
Posted : 6 years, 4 months ago at Mar 24 22:33 -
Thats a good point about Michael not being able to die, but i wouldnt test it too far! The Island may be keeping him alive, but for how long??!

I dont think it is Sayid in the coffin, or Michael, mainly because for some reason or another somebody would have been at the funeral, and Jack has no real connection to them more than anyone else, so there is no reason for him to go alone to the funeral etc. It has to be somebody Jack has a connection with surely? Its probably going to wind out as some kind of cop out, eg a character we haven't met yet.
Moderator
Rank : 34
Posted : 6 years, 4 months ago at Mar 24 22:40 -
Jack expected to see Kate there, which was the only reason he attended. Considering all the chairs set-up, they was expecting someone! Jack was surprised when he walked in to see no one. So if anything, Kate was someone that was meant to be there, which would point to a character she is close too.

It was in a 'Black' Neighbourhood which is why it might be Michael but then he was based in New York.