The Ups: The sword fight on the wheel is old-fashioned fun of the type that made the first one great. The scenes between Johnny Depp and Keira Knightley are fun. Bill Nighy makes an interesting character. Darker in tone and more ambition doesn't always mean it's better as the characters are ruined and are not that fun anymore. Miss the lightness of the first one. Too much effects, sea monsters and supernatural creatures. Noisy. Naomie Harris is terribly annoying and wooden. Too long. The canni"