When IMDb and Rotten Tomatoes disagree (59 movies items)
"Rotten Tomatoes: 82%
It was a Tim Burton film! But still audiences weren't too chuffed about it. Perhaps they compared it to the innovative original, and the score is a backlash against remakes. More realistically, they were obviously disappointed with the film itself. True, it was unusual, but you have to expect that from Tim Burton. Critics were more sympathetic. Thanks to DragonPhoenix for this one.