Movie Exchange Program - The Listal Group
Jaytoast - First Package
February 2012 - Send to - the giraffe
Arrived Safe and Sound April 2012 - Forward to - Xanadon't Arrived Safe and Sound June 2012 - Forward to - phillydude Arrived Safe and Sound August 2012 - Return to - Jaytoast MIA ================================================ The Giraffe - First Package
February 2012 - Send to - Xanadon't
Arrived Safe and Sound April 2012 - Forward to - phillydude Arrived Safe and Sound June 2012 - Forward to - Jaytoast Arrived Safe and Sound August 2012 - Return to - the giraffe Arrived Safe and Sound ================================================ Xanadon't - First Package
February 2012 - Send to - phillydude
Arrived Safe and Sound April 2012 - Forward to - Jaytoast Arrived Safe and Sound June 2012 - Forward to - the giraffe Arrived Safe and Sound August 2012 - Return to - Xanadon't Arrived Safe and Sound ================================================ Phillydude - First Package
February 2012 - Send to - Jaytoast
Arrived Safe and Sound April 2012 - Forward to - the giraffe Arrived Safe and Sound June 2012 - Forward to - Xanadon't Arrived Safe and Sound August 2012 - Return to - phillydude Arrived Safe and Sound ================================================ Jaytoast - Second Package
August 2012 - Send to - the giraffe
Arrived Safe and Sound September 2012 - Forward to - Xanadon't Arrived Safe and Sound November 2012 - Forward to - phillydude Arrived Safe and Sound December 2012 - Return to - Jaytoast ETA ================================================ The Giraffe - Second Package
August 2012 - Send to - Xanadon't
Arrived safe and sound September 2012 - Forward to - phillydude Arrived safe and sound November 2012 - Forward to - Jaytoast Skipped December 2012 - Return to - the giraffe Arrived Safe and Sound ================================================ Xanadon't - Second Package
August 2012 - Send to - phillydude
Arrived Safe and Sound September 2012 - Forward to - Jaytoast Skipped November 2012 - Forward to - the giraffe Arrived Safe and Sound December 2012 - Return to - Xanadon't ETA ================================================ Phillydude - Second Package
August 2012 - Send to - Jaytoast
Shipped - ETA August 2nd Package MIA September 2012 - Forward to - the giraffe Arrived safe and sound November 2012 - Forward to - Xanadon't Arrived Safe and Sound December 2012 - Return to - phillydude ETA ================================================ |
People who voted for this also voted for
Explore
Forums
Join Listal
Movies
TV Shows
DVDs
Music
Books
Games
Lists
Reviews
Images






















































If we are going to do a package every other month... then I say we skip December and that leaves us with only 5 packages a year.
November 2012 should be the month that we decide if we are going to continue in 2013. If we want to keep it every other month or feel comfortable enough to go to monthly.
This... way... in 2013 first package can start in January and if only doing every other month.... will give us 6 packages.
Anyway, this sounds great!
As I said, my initial thought for the 5 movies to send out were 5 Clint Eastwood movies :
The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
Bridges of Madison County
Unforgiven
In The Line of Fire
The Dirty Harry four pack of movies
but if that is to much Clint I have some ideas for possible substitutions
Quick Change (A Bill Murray movie I love that I noticed nobody else has seen)
Empire of the Sun (One of my favorite Spielberg movies I also notice nobody has seen)
Trading Places (Was thinking about including it since it shows off Philadelphia so well, on top off being a great movie - Eddie Murphy back when he was funny)
Crimson Tide( my favorite Denzel Washington movie)
I have noticed their are a number of 80's movies that not everybody has seen, so I would be happy to help get you caught up - so let me know which movies you are interested in.
Phillydude
I think the only thing that is keeping me at this moment is making sure I watched all the extras on "Clean Shaven" before it needs to leave home and if "Enter The Void" makes the whole package way too... pretentious and depressing.
OK, sorry to those people who aren't part of this group. Normally, I wouldn't make this list public (I don't even bother making most of my film diaries public) but it is the only way for the other members to see if a comment has been made on the list.
I'm up for all the movies you mentioned, phillydude. I haven't seen any of those films. And you can always do an 80s or Philly package next time around, since if we all watch the films 2 per month from each package we'll be done with them in September at the latest (earlier if some films have been seen already by someone, unless we're all committed to watching the films regardless of whether we've already seen them). So we'll all need to plan one more package for the rest of the year.
Also to jaytoast, I haven't seen The Secret in Their Eyes. :P
If I figured it out correctly, then in September we'd watch the last film from each package, plus one from the next. That means the 2nd packages will each get one viewing by years' end if we skip December (which I'm fine with...the holidays throw everything off). So it looks like we'll be carrying this over into next year, which is fine by me.
All right, off to finally decide which films I'm putting together for my package. jaytoast I'll send you a message about those shortly to add to the list.
After all the packages have gone around & been sent back to their owners, what if each owner watches the films he sent out at the same rate of 2 per month (so one for August, 2 for Sept., etc.)? Then we could re-watch the films we sent out after having seen each person's feedback & give our thoughts in our respective journals in response to the feedback we've received. Thus potentially looking at the films in another way or seeing things we missed but someone else picked up on. That would stretch the project out longer.
And if that idea is cool with everyone, then I say we take a break in October for our horror focus as well. That way the project runs through November & leaves December as a break. Thus we can all put off worrying about a 2nd package until next year.
And perhaps when we focus on horror we can all agree on a pair of films we'll all definitely watch, just in keeping with our interactive spirit. :)
All right, I need sleep...just had to drop back by & leave this while thinking about it lest it keep me awake longer.
Okay, so I'm afraid I'm already a bit confused. My initial impression was that we were all sending out 5 of our own packages per year, one every two months if you cut-out January (obviously) and December. And that each package would make its rounds thru the other three members over the course of those TWO months. (Er, so let's see... if everyone does a 5-film package, that makes 15 movies per 2 months. A 4-film package would be 12 per 2 months.)
But possibly that was never the plan, as it now sounds as though we're each assembling one package in February and sending it off. Then EACH member has a 2 month window in which to watch those 5 movies before forwarding it to the next member. Is that the case?
Ha, I swear I'll be really good at all of this once I'm clear on the logistics.
Anyway, haven't seen anything mentioned so far that I would positively object to watching. I'm under-schooled on Eastwood and could lift my Speilberg boycott long enough to watch Empire of the Sun, a film my sister actually recommended I see not all that long ago.
And jaytoast, I'll leave the decision about Enter the Void up to you, but you know that I need a kick in the ass when it comes to watching that one...
Any other ideas mentioned I'll hold off on weighing in on until I'm familiar with the basics ;)
So we start with 4 packages of 5 films (one package from each of us) to rotate among us. I don't see the need to pass along new packages before the originals make their way back to their owners. Make sense?
I'm not sure why jaytoast thought we had to do 5 packages.
1 in April and then the second movie for April will be the first movie from your package. My 5 movies will go to jaytoast in February, you in April, Xanadon't in June and back to me in August - do I have that right?
I like the idea of watching our own 5 movies again after reading everyone's comments. Then the horrorfest is for October and in November we discuss how we will continue in 2013 - either making it monthly or sticking with the two month system.
It makes sense to skip over the holidays and start fresh in January again.
I think I settled on the 5 I will be sending -
The Good, The Bad and the Ugly
Unforgiven
In The Line Of Fire
Empire Of The Sun
Quick Change
And I like the idea of putting together an 80's package for next time - looking forward to getting started :)
Exactly. Looking forward to your films! Mine should be added here soon I think. :)
I thought we would just keep the packages for two months before moving onwards. The 1/2 is going to kill my brain.
I was only including a fifth 'extra' film because I figured that there would be at least one film from each package that someone from the group has already seen.
Since the timing works that we should be getting our first package sent back to us in August. Perhaps that is the date that we can decide on if we want to switch to four a month?
Even then it wouldn't be quite monthly...
Proposal...
August our second package of four movies goes out...
August - Send Four Out
September - Forward
October - Skip for Horrorfest
November - Forward
December - Skip for Christmas
Jan - Package Returned to owner
Any'who... that is just a thought. I still need to work out what I'm going to send. Xanadon't has seen the films that I was planning on sending.
I tend to agree.
I should have a 5-pack put together by this time tomorrow. Ooo, I'm excited!
I have been trying to figure out how I'm going to introduce Blu Ray into my life. It might happen this year but it isn't very high on my list right now.
Oh, and have you seen Aronofsky's Pi? Looks like you've watched it, but haven't rated it.
I have been putting it off because I already replaced my VCR tapes with DVDs, and don't really want to replace everything again - but that seems to be the direction movies are headed so I probably will buy one eventually - does Blu Ray require a HD Television?
OK, cool. That's fine by me. And I'm also OK with deciding on the next package once the first ones are on their way back (or perhaps even better deciding on them shortly BEFORE we send the packages back).
Looks like Xanadon't is the only one of us with Blu-ray then. Always good to know I'm not the lone hold-out. ;)
Is everyone fine with the movies I have listed for them so far?
My package is pretty much 'set' even if it does have two movies Xanadon't has seen but just think... now you can watch the bonus features! Ha!
Who's That Knocking at My Door?
Notorious (Hitch)
Pi
Roman Holiday
Lady Vengeance (This is a color film, but includes a bonus "fade to white" version if anyone's interested)
I feel like this is more or less "set", though it appears the giraffe didn't much care for Lady Vengeance. Sorry man... if you object I could replace it with something else entirely different.
I will be watching the 31 days of Oscar next month, so B&W movies will fit right in - I went with sort of an actors theme - three have Clint and two have John Malkovich - I thought about Crimson Tide for the 5th movie to make 2 Gene Hackmans, but decided on Quick Change instead for a little comic relief :)
@Xanadon't - No worries on Lady Vengeance...either I'll re-watch it to see if I like it more now or I can skip it.
And as far as my films go, Black Snake Moan & Young @ Heart have a common theme of music; Shaolin Soccer & Kung Fu Hustle both came from the same director (Stephen Chow); and Versus is a zombie/samurai/gangster movie which COULD fit in with Stephen Chow's films & I think complements jaytoast's package theme also.
So we should send these off next week, yes?
And I already told Xanadon't, but mine has been sent (yesterday) & is slated for delivery to him on Feb. 2nd.
Oh, and while I'm thinking about it...going forward shall we all refer to our project as "Movies via Post" on our monthly lists? I want to be sure so that when I start watching these I can title the section appropriately. ;)
I think "Movies via Post" sounds better then "Packages by Mail" the constant use of the term "package" seems illicit. The most common abbreviation of MvP, would be "Most Valuable Player". So, even abbreviated I think it works.
Welcome to "Things I have thought *way* too much about" hope you enjoyed your visit LOL ;)
All right off to watch something....
Looks like Mr X might have the last word on this one.
you certainly packed your movies better than I packed mine, but at least now I know what to do for the next leg of their journey.
Way to go gang! Look at the diligence- all 4 of us on the ball!
Movie Exchange Program sounds just fine to me. It's probably better than talking about each others packages all month ;)
I've been trying to think of a cinematic variation of chain-letter, or pen-pal, or shipping and handling, or something, but I'm drawing a big fat blank.
Okay, well I plan on diving right in with one title later tonight, but maybe don't hold me to it.
Hahahahahahaha :D Yes, do that!
Glad to know everyone's movies reached their destinations safely. Looking forward to digging into these myself, though I may wait until next week to do so.
@Xanadon't - You're welcome! I'm sure you'll enjoy that, and was thankful for the opportunity to finally give that to you. And indeed I think it's best we not spend the rest of the month/year talking about each other's packages haha.
watch one every 10 days after that - Can't wait to
see Notorious - Nothing like classic Hitchcock :)
it was a great way to wrap up the weekend.
So, I should be sending my films off on Monday and then updating my journal entry.
Now I'm off to sleep....
ANY'WHO... If it isn't that big of a deal for Mr Giraffe. Would it be a problem to send the movies on the 3rd and that way you would get them by the weekend? Might give you a head start on the dollars trilogy ;)
And yes... my mental impairment regarding making people editors of a list has been cured and you should ALL be editors of this list now.
And just so this comment isn't entirely repetitive (since I replied to jaytoast via message), I see where I can edit the list now. So yes, that worked!
p.s.--Excellent choice dude, snickerdoodles are my favorite.
I hope you had a great vacation... I was just starting to miss you ;)
And that reminds me of one of the times we left town for a few days last year...our neighbor was supposed to check on our cat while we were gone & when we came back there was no sign he'd ever been by. Water bowl was empty, litter box full...good times. Guess who has never been asked to check on anything at our house since? ;)
Ha, yes you see we normally have someone that's terrific about looking after things anytime we travel. But she recently underwent a medical procedure, and we didn't want to put her up to the task this time around. Doesn't sound like our substitute cat-checker-onner was as grossly negligent as yours, (holy shit, seriously? Water bowl low with food particles and whatnot floating around in it isn't very impressive, but empty?! That's pretty damn distressing) but all evidence points to a borderline failing grade. Which sucks, cuz we always like to express our gratitude with some kind of cool gift/gesture but...well I'm not exactly inspired to run out and purchase any restaurant gift cards or spa packages.
Any problems with these picks? Ah, and ya... they have nothing in common with each other.
Art School Confidential (good, relatively obscure compared to some films on the list)
Broken Embraces (newer Almodovar)
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (near essential viewing in terms of its cast- Liz Taylor, Paul Newman)
Inland Empire (Lynch- haven't yet watched myself, daunting proposition)
The Life Aquatic (Wes Anderson)
The Man Who Wasn't There (B&W Coen Brothers)
Miracle (good hockey flick)
Rendition
Super
Talk to Her (was my introduction to Almodovar)
Thumbsucker
Tennis, Anyone? (Good, but there are better films in the list- included mostly because you're not likely to come across it any-old-where)
Win, Win
I've got a few I'm leaning toward but figure all of you should exercise the power to veto one or more films from the list. Fire away.
@Xanadon't Almost everything you listed is in my queue so I would be grateful for any clearing of queue space. Except for "Tennis, Anyone?" which I have never heard of before and will now have to hunt it down on IMDb.
@Everyone... OK, so I was the shmuck who brought this up on the list when it could have been done via email... but I have been thinking if we are still toying with the idea of adding a horror film. We might as well. The fact that it being October or not hardly seems to prevent any of us from watching a horror film ;)
So, just a quick thought on the 'yet undecided third film' ;)
And really most everything else "Horror" in my collection fall into one of two camps: "Stuff You've Already Seen" and "Crap".
@Xanadon't The fecal content of a film has never been an automatic disqualification for a film to take up residency in my queue LOL
Awesome- I very nearly rented The Haunting yesterday. Now I'm glad I didn't!
@Xanadon't - Nothing in your list I'd outright vote down, though I'll offer for your consideration that I have The Man Who Wasn't There in my IQ & the one time I got my hands on a copy of Life Aquatic it wouldn't play past the first 25 minutes or so & I've never bothered to try it again. Wes Anderson seems very hit or miss with me.
@Xanadon't - The Martyrs is fine for the horror selection - I haven't heard of it before, but when it comes to movies I will try anything once :) of the movies you listed the only one I have seen is Miracle, I didn't like it that much because I watched the real thing in 1980, so there wasn't much mystery in the movie for me.
@the giraffe - love the idea of the Dr. Jekyll double feature - I am especially interested in the one with Spencer Tracy - and I am steal leaning toward Psycho II as my horror selection.
Think I'll be sending out 25th Hour, Talk to Her, and Martyrs. And no, not much of anything in common except that all 3 are films that I responded strongly toward in one way or another.
Gandhi
Sophie's Choice
(I am surprised nobody has those two marked as watched, so they are the front runners at the moment, especially since it is their 30th anniversaries this year)
Some other possibilities
The Way We Were
Same Time Next Year
Trading Places
Coming to America
Crimson Tide
Terms Of Endearment
The Right Stuff
A Soldier's Story
Murphy's Romance
@the giraffe Thanks for updating the list. Yep, back from the beach but now I think I need a few days to recover.
I will let you know on the ETA.
Have a great weekend everyone!
But yeah, I'll jump back on here with an ETA when I know more...
Hope everyone has a great weekend!
I've got a busy weekend ahead too. Was hoping to get my last film watched last night but it didn't work out. Odds are I'll send the package off on Wednesday, unless by some strange magic I get it watched before Monday. But then again if you're leaving town then Wednesday may be best anyway.
Really didn't get as much watch this month as I had hoped but still this month should wrap up nicely.
Xanadon't, I look forward to watching your second round movies.
jaytoast, my 2nd package is all ready to be shipped out tomorrow as long as you are around.
And like jaytoast, the beginnings of my movie journal aren't even on the horizon yet...
I think there might still be a few dvds from the 'not so official exchange program' floating out there if so... hold on to them. There is no point in sending them to me until this matter is resolved.
I sent a message via google groups... not sure if anyone got the message. Hum, perhaps I'm just cursed this month. Given the option between being incompetent or cursed... I'm sticking with cursed.
I was mildly under the impression that the post-office might deal with the insurance claim but I guess that gets forwarded to the "Snow Ball in Hell" department. I have yet to get a response from anyone.... about anything.
@jaytoast - Good to know that USPS continues to live up to its poor reputation. At the same time though it'd be better if they'd acknowledge your existence at least. Should phillydude, Xanadon't, and I start calling them incessantly on your behalf? ;)
@jaytoast - if you haven't moved by the holidays, it is possible that I could bring your movies out to Portland myself if you want, as I will be visiting my brother again for Christmas, and you could pick them up while I am there.
@ All - what is the plan going into 2013?
Option 1: We keep it going. This may entail finding one or two Listal members to participate for next year first, depending on whether jaytoast wants to bow out at this point (which would be totally understandable). Then of course we have to figure out the number of movies & whatnot after we know who's participating.
Option 2: We keep it going, but just not as an official ongoing project. I know we've all exchanged movies outside of those designated specifically for the project, and I think it's safe to say we've been enjoying doing so.
Option 3: Start a new project. This will require some thought & discussion as to what it might be. Perhaps instead of exchanging films we could watch certain films each month that are available for streaming online (preferably free or else cheap, just to make it easier on everyone...or via Netflix though not all of us use it at this point).
Option 4: Quit. Definitely not a choice I'd support though as I think overall this has been a lot of fun. ;)
Thanks to the giraffe for laying it out- I feel like you pretty much covered everything so far as options going forward. To be honest, right now I'm hesitant to commit to proceeding in the manner we have been for another year. This project has certainly been a good deal of fun, but over the last couple months I've been struggling a bit with it, whether it be sitting down with whichever movies, sending them in a timely fashion (as evident above) or just feeling like I'm into it and having a good time, rather than MEP just feeling at times like "one more thing". That's wear I'm at personally, and I don't know that my enthusiasm/engagement will change for the better (return to what it was) in the coming months.
That said, it is cool that we've all exchanged movies upon our own volition in certain instances and I'm not opposed to sending something someone's way if/when it comes to my attention that there's a desire/usefulness. Or receiving them now and then.
As for option 3, I think I'd be more suited to a streaming thing than the commitment of exchanging movies physically. I know that the giraffe was particularly good about rewatching his own movies after getting them back and newly equipped with all the other members' feedback. But I sucked at, big time. In a streaming scenario there are probably fewer limitations than operating from personal collections. And I imagine most often the movie would be new to everyone, which I think would be kind of cool.
I do have a Netflix instant account, buy I'm not opposed to relying upon other formats at a reasonable cost. (Most amazon instant watches, Vudu rentals, etc aren't any more expensive than postage.)
So yeah, I guess at this stage I'm leaning toward a sorta funky combination of options 2 & 3. But by all means, if you guys would rather keep things rocking the way it's been, certainly don't let my 2 cents sway you. If that's the case I'd certainly reconsider things before making a decision to stay fully on board or gracefully bow out. And even if I did step aside, you know I'd still be scoping out everyone's journal every month to see what's going on :)
I still have one movie rented in October that I still haven't bothered to glance at and now I sort of wonder where it is under all the preparing to move/packing clutter. Hum...
I'll have to think about my Listal commitment and ponder some ideas.
I know most stream through Netflix or Amazon but have you checked MUBI out yet?
I guess the one thing that I would miss about the dvd's was watching films that were lesser known or forgotten. OK, well my brain is fried and I'm going to hobble to the store just for some fresh air.
Could be kinda cool too if we could watch them around the same time somehow, though I know we've all got different schedules, commitments, and what have you. So maybe just stick with getting whichever film(s) watched each month.
And again, if anyone is interested in continuing to share films via the mail we can do that too, just maybe outside of the project. I've still got a stack of films sitting here that aren't part of our project to watch, and every month they get pushed aside for one reason or another. Hoping to get some of them worked in this month and/or next, but we'll see.
I would be more keen on trying to watch the films around the same time with (given my lapse) skipping a month not being a huge flaw in other member's viewing experience.
I'll start digging around for online movies this week for next year. Would y'all like me to make a list for us to submit suggestions & then vote on which films we want to do? Or maybe one list for us to come up with ideas & then a public list for everyone (meaning all of Listal, if anyone else wants to participate) to vote on our picks? Just an idea I'm kicking around in my head. Let me know.
Off now to enjoy what's left of my Sunday before work...
I forgot to mention that if you respond to the email make sure you hit "Reply All"! Sending messages via the group turned out to be very unreliable. If you don't get an email from me... let me know.