Join Listal here 
Existing members 
Login here 
Join Listal to create lists, share images, get recommendations and much more
Added by Pumpkinate

on 22 Oct 2011 02:10

2126 Views 3 Comments

Mario Games We'd Like to See

Choose file... or enter url:
Sort by: Showing 11 items

Pumpkinate's Ideas

The following entries are written by PK (me!).
People who added this item 11  Average listal rating (5 ratings) 7  IMDB Rating
1. Ecco The Dolphin: Defender of the Future - Sega Dreamcast
An 3D Mario Taking Place Underwater

The water bits in video games have gotten a bad rep. Usually gamers don't like being hindered by that translucent blue stuff, and often the level designers can't fix this fact despite their best efforts.

I've always noted the potential of marine platformers, as games like Starfy and Ecco are more unique for their water-based gameplay. Mario should go underwater at some point, using different suits to interact with the water world in ways not possible on the surface.

People who added this item 1145  Average listal rating (697 ratings) 7.8  IMDB Rating
2. Grand Theft Auto III - PlayStation 2
A 3D Mario Taking Place in an Urban City

Grand Theft Auto III has been consistently cited as a progression from Super Mario 64. But what the heck kind of personality does Claude bring to the table? Not enough, I say!

Let's face it: Mario does it best. I say someone make an urban sandbox game with that classic 3D Mario charm. And no hookers! It may be the oldest profession, but it's getting old.

For whatever reason, I prefer 3D platformers with more surrealism and cartoony art direction. Since Mario has been consistently good, and Sonic's already tackled and conquered the realistic setting with Sonic Adventure and Sonic Adventure 2, I patiently await a Mario game in this style.

People who added this item 64  Average listal rating (21 ratings) 8.1  IMDB Rating
3. Sonic Colors - Nintendo Wii
A 3D Mario Taking Place in a Theme Park

I was reading through a Nintendo Power a few years ago, and one of the people in the letters page was asking for a Nintendo theme park. But let's compromise: We can make a Nintendo/Mario theme park in video game form! What could go wrong? I mean, besides not being safely fastened to the roller coaster and falling off at the loopty-loop!? Or spontaneously combusting while waiting in the lines!? There's plenty of danger awaiting Mario in an adventure like this. Buy your ticket several seasons in advance.

People who added this item 73  Average listal rating (24 ratings) 7.7  IMDB Rating
4. Dante's Inferno: Divine Edition - PlayStation 3
A 3D Mario Taking Place in the Afterlife

The only thing that could possibly take it a step further from Super Mario Galaxy is Super Mario Afterlife. It'd be cool to see Mario in some sort of Nintendo version of heaven, especially if there's a crisis on earth that requires his heroism and he has to go through the process of earning his way back to the land of the living by collecting stars and defeating bosses.

Hey, I didn't say it needed to be accurate! Just imagine the possibilities if Mario could speak to deceased Nintendo characters and bosses - not to mention face the wrath of the thousands of Goombas he's flattened!

People who added this item 305  Average listal rating (176 ratings) 8.7  IMDB Rating
5. Super Metroid - Super famicom and SNES
A Metroidvania Mario Game

Imagine non-linear Mario in 2D form. Yeah, it kind of blows your mind, doesn't it? See Metroidvanias We'd Like to See for this and similar proposals.

Sabin Kenobi's Ideas

The following entries are written by Sabin Kenobi.
People who added this item 23  Average listal rating (14 ratings) 7.1  IMDB Rating
6. Marvel vs. Capcom 2 - PlayStation Network

There are plenty of Mario characters now to make this happen, something like street fighter or Marvel Vs Capcom 2 (the good one). I'd love to see Luigi get revenge for all the time's he's been left out. Some might say Smash Bro's suffice's as a fighting game, but if it were intricate with more special moves and combos it could be much more in depth.

People who added this item 40  Average listal rating (19 ratings) 7.8  IMDB Rating
7. Unreal Tournament III - PlayStation 3

Not real sure how it would work, something like Unreal Tournament would be awesome, it's just a genre I don't believe Mario has touched on. He had that weird gun in Mario Sunshine (it was a gun wasn't it?), I wouldn't really know I never played it. But anyway, give them guns for no reason and have them run around shooting each other, it would still be awesome. Again, Luigi's revenge is at hand!

People who added this item 649  Average listal rating (407 ratings) 8  IMDB Rating
8. StarCraft - PC Games
RTS (Real Time Strategy)

This could be cool or lame, be like Starcraft, building a town of mushroom people or goombas if you're the bad guy, having Mario and Bowser as hero's and trying to take down the whole mushroom kingdom! There could be all kinds of warriors and classes, lots of room for ideas here.

People who added this item 49  Average listal rating (25 ratings) 7.4  IMDB Rating
9. Gauntlet: Dark Legacy - PlayStation 2
4 player action game

This is one they definitely should do, something like Marvel Ultimate Alliance or Gauntlet. You could do Mario, Luigi, Peach and Toad, or even pull a Mario RPG and put Bowser in but I always thought that was lame, and just run around all 4 of you. It would be way better than the Wii NEW Super Mario because it'd be more top down view and action oriented, different characters with different move-sets and abilities.

People who added this item 129  Average listal rating (73 ratings) 8.2  IMDB Rating
10. Star Wars: Battlefront II - PlayStation 2

I didn't know what else you call this mode but basically star wars battlefront but in Mario. Little mushroom dudes and goombas would be your main trooper. This would probably flop since the LOTR Conquest game did because these games need projectiles, melee characters just don't cut it. Regardless, I would still buy it because I love the genre and I grew up on Mario.

People who added this item 161  Average listal rating (65 ratings) 8.3  IMDB Rating
11. Infamous 2 - PlayStation 3
Level Creator

One other game idea I would love to see is a 2-d sidescroller like the old days but with a level creator! They thought Lost Levels was tough? I want to build something INSANE! This would sell like wildfire, we've been playing 2-d Mario all our lives and they haven't let us build our own. Even Excitebike had a level creator, and with something more complex like LBP and Infamous 2 having level creation it's time we made our own Mario levels.


Salute your Red, White and Blue!

Think Mario exhausted his possibilities with the Super Mario Galaxy series? Think again! This list offers some ideas for the themes and gameplay elements that could work in future Mario games. Most of them avoid trying to top Super Mario Galaxy by simply being unique on a smaller scale, while one is probably the only thing that could be more ethereal than soaring the stars.

Added to

40 votes
Lists that deserve more votes (65 lists)
list by Mr. Saturn
Published 1 year, 10 months ago 7 comments

Related lists

I'd like to follow
9 item list by Andre Dantas
5 votes 1 comment
Impossible Games that Kill Gamers' Souls
15 item list by Mr. Lays
33 votes 4 comments
The Best Main Mario Games
20 item list by Ryguy
The early gaming years..
9 item list by Dav1d
Top Celebrities I'd Like To Have A Beer With
16 item list by PvtCaboose91
3 votes 1 comment
I'd Like To See Them Togather
18 item list by Casanova
Mario RPG series
8 item list by Prelude
8 votes
Mario Party series
11 item list by Prelude
11 votes 1 comment
Movie origins I'd like to see
8 item list by Lexie
16 votes 8 comments
Wario series
17 item list by Prelude
8 votes 1 comment

View more top voted lists

People who voted for this also voted for

3DS Games - ranked by preference
Licensed Video Games Worth Playing
Can't Miss RPGS
Games I ♥
Games I've beaten
Favorite nds rpg
My Gaming Firsts
"MAKE WAY FOR DA BIG DAWG!" - A Final Fantasy List
30-ish criminally underrated games
Games Developed or Published by Atlus
Game Over
Advance Remakes

More lists from Pumpkinate

PK's 30 Video Games Meme
PK's Favorite Video Game Series
PK's All-Time Favorite Movies
PK's All-Time Favorite Video Games
PK's Favorite Video Game Covers
Favorite Video Game Music


Posted: 2 years, 10 months ago at Oct 25 16:25
"Hell Yeas!" That's my witty comment on this list. But that's the first thing I thought of. Some great idea you had there! C:
Thank god, finally sb. wants more underwater as well x3
Posted: 2 years, 2 months ago at Jun 28 18:10
Metroidvania Mario. Wow, never thought of that before. I like it.
Posted: 2 years, 2 months ago at Jul 3 3:47
Hey, it's only a matter of time before Mario does just about every genre! =P

Login or Signup to post a comment