Join Listal here 
Existing members 
Login here 
Join Listal to create lists, share images, get recommendations and much more
Added by ape

on 12 Jun 2011 12:28

3381 Views 7 Comments

Good Guy or Bad Guy?

Choose file... or enter url:
Sort by: Showing 16 items

Good Guy

People who added this item 331  Average listal rating (170 ratings) 8.7  IMDB Rating
1. Red Dead Redemption - PlayStation 3
Not sure why, but I had no desire to be a bad guy in this game...Maybe it's because the wildlife was enough of a threat to my survival and I didn't want the pain of the law hunting me down added onto that, but in Red Dead Redemption, I was a good little lad.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 552  Average listal rating (314 ratings) 8.6  IMDB Rating
2. BioShock - Xbox 360
There's no real difference in being a good guy or bad guy here aside from slightly different dialogue and ending based on your alignment...I just enjoy saving children rather than, well, murdering them, basically.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 559  Average listal rating (306 ratings) 8.3  IMDB Rating
3. Mass Effect - Xbox 360
Like Red Dead, not sure why I chose to be the good guy here. But I've played through this game twice, and both times, without meaning to, I ended up down the path of Mr. Nice Guy.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 142  Average listal rating (81 ratings) 9  IMDB Rating
4. Mass Effect 2 - PlayStation 3
There's something about the Mass Effect games...I really have no desire to be evil. It's weird. I always end up being one of those paragon fellows....And I also always end up sleeping with aliens.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 90  Average listal rating (44 ratings) 8.6  IMDB Rating
5. Mass Effect 3 - PlayStation 3
The Mass Effect good guy streak has continued on...As has the adult relations with alien species....Though it seems like your actions really have little to no effect on anything in the game, aside from the ending....Which seems to have nothing to do with your alignment so much as it has to do with the final decision that you make....So, your choices during the course of the three games don't really have a "mass" effect, now do they? Oh, yeah. I went there.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 202  Average listal rating (100 ratings) 7.2  IMDB Rating
6. Fable III - Xbox 360
Fable was a game where I always really, really enjoyed being a bad guy. Fable II continued in that trend. Then I played this and was very disappointed that it was less fun to continue my evil ways in this game. The game is also more challenging at the end if you remain good, which motivated me to continue on down the path of good since the majority of the game is a real breeze to beat...And usually in a boring sort of way. But anyway, Fable III ended my reign of terror on Albion. Hopefully the next Fable game will entice me to rejoin the dark side.
ape's rating:

Bad Guy

People who added this item 42  Average listal rating (21 ratings) 8.5  IMDB Rating
7. Ogre Battle: The March of the Black Queen - Super famicom and SNES
Because I chose to spend time leveling up my armies, I often found myself beating up on weaker armies in the game, which the game takes as sending you down the path of evil, since you're picking on the weak.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 410  Average listal rating (232 ratings) 7.6  IMDB Rating
8. Fable - Xbox
I can't play this game as a good guy. I just can't. I try, and I end up being evil. I end up breaking into houses, stealing items, and murdering people...Heck, I've murdered folks just so their house would go up for sale so I could buy it. And yes, I sided with the bully in the beginning of the game and socked that whiny brat right in the eye.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 421  Average listal rating (212 ratings) 7.7  IMDB Rating
9. Fable II - Xbox 360
Just like with the original Fable, I just have too much fun being evil that I can't even imagine being good. I've made the effort, but I can't steal and murder as a good guy...So the attempt ultimately ends in failure.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 230  Average listal rating (114 ratings) 8.2  IMDB Rating
10. Fallout 3 - PlayStation 3
Same with Fable, I just enjoy pick pocketing and breaking into houses to steal stuff. My particular favorite is stealing from a store at night, then coming back later that morning to sell the stolen items back to the store they were stolen from. I also enjoy the old "plant a landmine in their pants" gag when someone in-game sasses me. I can't do this stuff as a good guy, which is why I've got no desire to be one in the Wasteland.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 104  Average listal rating (38 ratings) 8.3  IMDB Rating
11. Fallout: New Vegas - PlayStation 3
Name the reasons listed for Fallout 3, then add in the ability to lead a robot army and assassinate the president of the Wasteland USA, and you've got even more reasons to be a bit of a jerk during the course of the game.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 67  Average listal rating (21 ratings) 7.2  IMDB Rating
12. Silent Hill: Downpour - PlayStation 3
Apparently, killing the disfigured creatures trying to murder you is a bad thing, as the more you murder, the "badder" you are...Even if you're extremely nice with every other aspect of your game. In order to be a good guy in Downpour, not only do you have to be nice to the few folks that you meet, but you also have to avoid killing things. I'm not against that, I just never really thought of fleeing when chopping down a screamer with an axe is so much gosh darn fun.
ape's rating:


People who added this item 25  Average listal rating (10 ratings) 7.5  IMDB Rating
13. Shin Megami Tensei - Super famicom and SNES
Shin Megami Tensei may be the first game to allow the character to choose an alignment that had a direct impact on the game and ending. The beauty of it? None of them are necessarily good or evil as the choices are Chaos, Neutral, and Law....And all three are both good and evil in their own ways, depending on your personal point of view of what's right and wrong. That being said, I'm usually right down the middle in the Neutral part of the game, unless I adjust to one alignment or another in an attempt to recruit a demon friend.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 134  Average listal rating (49 ratings) 8.3  IMDB Rating
14. Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne - PlayStation 2
I've beaten this game a few times, but most often with the Neutral alignment. Quite frankly, I'm not a huge fan of the worlds my 'friends' in the game want to create...As a result, I go down my own, neutral path and create the world the way I want to. I'm a rebel and a loner, Dottie.
ape's rating:

Chaos Alignment

People who added this item 33  Average listal rating (7 ratings) 8  IMDB Rating
15. Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor Overclock... - Nintendo 3DS
Like mentioned above, the Shin Megami Tensei series determines alignment differently, with no clear-cut 'good' or 'bad' alignment, leaving it up to the interpretation of the player to figure out what side is good and what side is bad. That being said, in Devil Survivor, I found myself in the Chaos alignment...The alignment that sympathizes with the demons...And hey, with Black Frost as a recruitable group leader, can you really blame me? Hearing adorable, high-pitched "hee hoo's" while Black Frost taunted enemies was more than enough reason for being Chaos.
ape's rating:

People who added this item 50  Average listal rating (18 ratings) 7.9  IMDB Rating
16. Shin Megami Tensei: Strange Journey - Nintendo DS
Another SMT game where I chose the path of Chaos. I usually like to go down the path of Neutral on the Megami Tensei games, but the angels really made me not want the world that they wanted to form...Sounded a bit like slavery to me...So, I went a tad overboard with my decisions to ensure that there'd be no way of me ending up on the Law side of things....And sure enough, the final few battles against the angels made me feel as if my decision was a correct one.
ape's rating:


This is more of a personal list to reference what alignment I took when playing games that have such a mechanic in them. Was I a good guy? A bad guy? Neutral? I dunno. That's why I made the list, ya dig?

Added to

8 votes
Favorite Gaming Lists (20 lists)
list by LordDarkrai
Published 3 years, 4 months ago 3 comments
33 votes
Kami-chan's Favourite Lists (60 lists)
list by Kamichan
Published 3 years, 5 months ago 8 comments
fav games (17 lists)
list by to2
Published 3 years, 2 months ago

Related lists

Good or Evil ?
44 item list by compcua
14 votes
We need to work together on this one
5 item list by Opalgem
1 votes
The Evolution of Danny Trejo
90 item list by diabolical dr voodoo
11 votes 1 comment
Good Guys Gone Bad
45 item list by SFG¿mystic
22 votes 9 comments
Ewan McGregor - Hot Guy
18 item list by siesmicforce
6 votes
Dystopian "Fathers" and Bad Dudes In Charge
21 item list by captaine
23 votes 1 comment
Ryan Reynolds-he's just so likable!
22 item list by ClaSSIc CiNEma
13 votes 2 comments
Jude Law - Hot Guy
17 item list by siesmicforce
4 votes
The Simpsons Guy
122 item list by filmbuilder
8 votes
Because the bad guy is always ugly
29 item list by My raimBow
55 votes 20 comments

View more top voted lists

People who voted for this also voted for

Gaming Diary
Games on GruntLogic's Agenda
PS1 Games with Underground Laboratories
Played in 2013
What is your Favorite Game Cover?
Meet the ROCKSTAR protagonists
30 Days of Video Games List
Played in 2012
The Top 10 2012 Games I Enjoyed Playing
25 best new characters of the decade
Most Unique Listal Lists!
Games Played in 2012

More lists from ape

Games of 2013 - ranked by preference
My Top Owned Game Franchises
Compilation of compilations
Genesis Games - ranked by preference
Top 100 Playstation One Games
iPhone Games - ranked by preference


Posted: 4 years, 2 months ago at Jun 13 10:05
Excellent. Have you played Knights of the Old Republic? The call of the darkside is powerful....
Posted: 4 years, 2 months ago at Jun 13 10:09
I have, but I don't recall much about being good or bad...I'm assuming that I was neutral. Then again, I never played through to the end...But, I've been planning on giving it another whirl in the future.

I can also put Jade Empire on this list eventually, but I can't remember which alignment I was in that game, either. My memory is pretty terrible.
Posted: 4 years, 2 months ago at Jun 15 4:06
We're making recommendations, right? I've heard the console version of Spider-Man: Web of Shadows lets the player choose between good and evil. The DS version is very light on this however.
Posted: 4 years, 2 months ago at Jun 17 14:47
I love your comments, fantastic list!
Posted: 3 years, 7 months ago at Jan 14 19:52
Brilliant comments! Hope you have had the chance to play Fable 3 the same way!
Posted: 3 years, 7 months ago at Jan 15 18:13
Hope you have had the chance to play Fable 3 the same way!

Not yet. I have Fable III, but haven't had an opportunity to play it yet. I look forward to when I get the chance to, though.

EDIT: Played through Fable III....Surprisingly enough, ended up down the path of the good guy. Added it to the list.
Edit: 3 years, 7 months ago
Posted: 1 year, 9 months ago at Dec 1 0:38
I can't blame you on Strange Journey. I almost at the part where you chose which path to go on, and there's no way I go to law. These soldiers during that cutscene were complete zombies. I almost considered chaos until deciding to pick neutral.

Login or Signup to post a comment