Join Listal here 
Existing members 
Login here 
Join Listal to create lists, share images, get recommendations and much more
Avatar
Added by Hobbit

on 13 Feb 2011 03:34

 
2
506 Views   No comments

Better in the book (Deathly Hallows part 1)

Sort by: Showing 6 items
Average listal rating (971 ratings) 6.7  IMDB Rating
1. Daniel Radcliffe

I have voiced my disappointment with Daniel Radcliffe before, and this is no exception.

His performance as Harry Potter was definitely better than before, but he was overshadowed, as always, by a terrific supporting cast. That includes Rupert Grint and Emma Watson, who were amazing. Dan really tried hard, I can see that, but the better performances really hindered him in my opinion.

He really doesn't scream Harry Potter to me. In the books, especially this one, Harry doesn't really feel like a hero, and that is what makes him believable and human. He doesn't want anything other than to be normal, and doesn't like that the fate of an entire world is resting on whether or not he fails. Dan really doesn't bring that through into his performance.

Average listal rating (560 ratings) 7.6  IMDB Rating
2. Bill Nighy

Rufus Scrimgeour should have been introduced in the Half Blood Prince, it would have given a better introduction to his character, like it did in the novel. Even a cameo in HBP would have been good, but he gets no mention until this film. In the film, we don't even know his name until after his death, even though he is prominently featured in the final two novels.

Bill Nighy's performance was great, but I wouldn't doubt it if people who hadn't read the books felt like he was useless.

Average listal rating (448 ratings) 6.6  IMDB Rating
3. Bonnie Wright

Coming into this film, I knew they weren't going to focus on Harry and Ginny's relationship all that much, but she has maybe ten minutes of screen time, if not less. She is Harry's future wife, and she gets barely any screen time in these films. Not to mention that all of her scenes make her seem a little bit slutty.

Bonnie Wright isn't the best actress, but giving her less and less to do won't help her improve.

Ginny is one of my favorite characters in this series. In the novel, she is a supportive friend of Harry and the only other person he's come into contact with who was also possessed by Voldemort. This is a big deal, and is one of the cornerstones of their relationship. She understands Harry and knows how to comfort him.

In the films she's a throw-away character.

Average listal rating (205 ratings) 6  IMDB Rating
4. Richard Griffiths
All you see of the Dursley's in this film is them leaving. I'm not sure I want to go into detail about how much this disappoints me.

Average listal rating (293 ratings) 7.2  IMDB Rating
5. Clémence Poésy

This is more about Bill than Fleur, so I'll be quick. The reason Fleur's actress is listed, is that Bill's does not have a profile on this site.

Bill Weasley was a character introduce in the novel Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. He works for the wizard bank Gringott's, and, in Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince he is engaged to Fleur Delacour. In the same novel he is injured by the werewolf Fenrir Greyback, which is a cause of great worry to his family. He is Ron's eldest brother.

I am giving this background information because it is not given in the films. Bill is first introduced in the film Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1. His relationship with Fleur in the film comes out of thin air, as it is not explained that they developed a relationship while he was teaching her to improve her English (yes, in the novels this is used as a euphemism)

Average listal rating (112 ratings) 6.9  IMDB Rating
6. Natalia Tena

Again, there is not much of Nymphadora Tonks. She happens to be another one of my favorite characters and it's disappointing to me that she is not featured more in the films.

Tonks is Remus Lupin's wife, and is a metamorphmagi. This means that she can change her appearance at will. There is almost no mention of this in the films, and she also has none of the personality that made her a good character.


 

Added to




Related lists

Bml93's Film Diary for 2012
272 item list by Bml93
57 votes 24 comments
IMDb Top 250 Movies (2011 Updated)
507 item list by novarc
18 votes 2 comments
Best Harry Potter films
8 item list by judmac1
23 votes 6 comments
2012 Movie Diary - January
27 item list by Bobbayyyyy
5 votes
2012 Movie Diary
120 item list by knight_
5 votes
Top Ten Movies of 2010
10 item list by CD Smiles
3 votes
Oscar nominations 2012
44 item list by propelas
25 votes 8 comments
Watched in 2013
146 item list by Lia
13 votes 1 comment
Movies that are better than the books
25 item list by garfield2710
1 votes

View more top voted lists
Join listal and create your own lists and much more

People who voted for this also voted for

Mocinhas fodas!
BEANIES♥
10 of the Best... Jessica
Quotes i agree with
Born in May
celebrities with pie in the face
Reigning Scream Queens!
always well dressed *-*
Cast For The Last Unicorn
30 List -- People
HOT MEN FROM Esquire(part 2)
Favorite Actresses

More lists from Hobbit

Green Eyes (work in progress)
the cast of Scream 4
Blue Eyes
I would send you hate mail if I cared enough
Live action versions of Disney characters
My Celebrity crushes(Male)



Login or Signup to post a comment