Avatar
Added by Kawaii

on 23 Jul 2011 09:04

 
20
4781 Views   9 Comments

Best Modern Stars to Play Classic Stars

Sort by: Showing 20 items
Average listal rating (95 ratings) 5.9  
1. Calista Flockhart
As older Audrey Hepburn.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (23 ratings) 7.2  
2. Anna Walton
As younger Audrey Hepburn.


Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (643 ratings) 6.9  
3. Kate Hudson


they could honestly not have made worst casting choices with Amy Adams and Zooey Deschanel. They have absolutely nothing in common with her- Amy's overacting and Zooey's underacting and the fact that both lack range are just bad. But then there's that they have totally different looks, personalities, and especially voices. Zooey's is a bit low but has no range and she has a classic 40s style of singing. Amy's is squeaky and smooth, the exact opposite of Janis's.

Kate not only looks like her (especially sans makeup) but she's a better actor than most people give her credit for (unlike Amy and Zooey, who are popular, which is probably why they got casted) and she looks great and natural in hippie clothes.
Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (1650 ratings) 7  
4. Drew Barrymore




Drew has quite a lot in common with Marilyn (the huge difference being I could never imagine Drew getting depressed, or succumbing to depression and offing herself; she's so bubbly and made with love, hope, and sparkles).
Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (166 ratings) 7.4  
5. Danielle Panabaker
As Judy Garland. She really does have Judy's girl-next-door beauty and has talent.

Kawaii's rating:

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (963 ratings) 7.6  
7. James Franco
As James Dean.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (607 ratings) 7.5  
8. Susan Sarandon
As Bette Davis.



With her daughter Eva as younger Bette:
Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (288 ratings) 6.9  
9. Gillian Anderson
As Joan Crawford.


Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (1187 ratings) 7.6  
10. Anne Hathaway
As Liza Minelli (daughter of Judy Garland).

Even though she's a HORRIBLE excuse for an actor and not the best singer, looks-wise she is right for Liz. Casting her as a legend like Judy was downright shameful.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (841 ratings) 8.1  
11. Joseph Gordon-Levitt
As Marlon Brando (since Heath is dead and Joseph is a good actor and looks just like Heath and Marlon).

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (1057 ratings) 6.9  
12. Gwyneth Paltrow
As Mia Farrow.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (929 ratings) 7.4  
13. Milla Jovovich
As Lauren Bacall.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (12 ratings) 8.6  
14. Anthony Bourdain
As Humphrey Bogart.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (474 ratings) 7.2  
15. Michelle Williams
As Jean Seberg. An absolutely perfect modern-day gamine, with perfect gaminesque hair and style that could rival Jean's or Audrey's.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (1389 ratings) 7.5  
16. George Clooney
As Clark Gable.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (179 ratings) 7.3  
17. Lily Collins
As young Elizabeth Taylor.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (1172 ratings) 7.1  
18. Winona Ryder
As older Elizabeth Taylor.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (566 ratings) 6.7  
19. Julia Stiles
As Sandra Dee. OK, yes, she's a little too exotic to look exactly like Sandra, but they do look a bit alike and Julia is a pretty underrated actor, as was Sandra.

Kawaii's rating:

Average listal rating (791 ratings) 7.4  
20. Michelle Pfeiffer
As Louise Brooks. And not just because she looks just like her here (albeit much more feminine than Brooks ever look IMO)- she's quite talented and looks younger than she is.

Kawaii's rating:



Added to

23 votes
Listal's Casting Lists (105 lists)
list by matchbox
Published 1 year, 3 months ago
2 comments



Related lists

Classic Stars Back In Film
15 item list by Bydusk
5 votes 2 comments
The Last Words of Classic Stars
19 item list by blankend
35 votes 3 comments
Watched in 2009
6 item list by Coma Comedian
5 votes 1 comment
Roger Ebert's "Zero Stars" -ratings
59 item list by Mustanaamio7
27 votes 16 comments
Cartoon Verzions of Classic Hollywood Stars
16 item list by blankend
5 votes
Adorable Animal Stars...
18 item list by Lex
7 votes
My Top TV Shows
53 item list by Origami Killer
9 votes 1 comment
Hot & Young Stars of Indian Cinema
32 item list by Ultimateone
10 votes 1 comment
Classic Female Stars Lists
179 item list by Fimc14
21 votes 1 comment
Classic Stars Paper Dolls
6 item list by ♥ мáя¢ια ♥
1 votes

View more top voted lists
Join listal and create your own lists and much more

People who voted for this also voted for

....Into the night....
Cecil Beaton Photography
The Untouchables Re-Cast
You know what they say about short guys
Vintage beauty
Smoking like Audrey
that 60's girl
Beautiful


Comments

Posted: 1 year, 9 months ago at Aug 26 13:38
Wow! an excellent list for sure! I just disagree with Calista for Audrey Hepburn YIKES! but that's my opinion haha
Posted: 1 year, 9 months ago at Aug 26 16:02
thanks! but you seriously dont like Calista? D; how come? I only ever saw one of her movies (Fragile) and she seemed to be a decent actor, and looks wise she matches her exactly.
Posted: 1 year, 8 months ago at Aug 31 23:08
You know, this is the first time I ever see you write stuff in positive light. Most of your other lists/comments usually revolve around people/celebs bashing, being sarcastic, hostile & bitchy, and/or lecturing us about you being supposedly CORRECT while the rest of us are all wrong and don't know anything. Your writings basically have a lot of negative energy in it.

Even when you try to make lists that are not supposed to bring anyone down yet the way you voice your opinions (esp when you compare your fave artists with the ones you consider unattractive/overrated) sounds like attacking other people and borderline harsh.

I understand that you may be knowledgeable about the things you talk about (although for the most part, you talk about things that are highly SUBJECTIVE, thus many of your opinion/taste differs a lot with mine), but the way you say/write it makes you come across to some people as rather rude, insensitive, crass, a douchebag or even -pardon the language- a b*tch!

So seeing this list where once in a while you don't give out (too much) crude remarks to some celebs (or basically ANYONE) and actually being "nice" without bashing anyone is a bit of a fresh air to me. I guess I should give you a medal and congratulate you for it.

This is by no way attacking you. Just a rather opinion of mine. Whether you want to see it as a constructive or destructive criticism, that's up for you to decide. I mean, if you can throw harsh critic and snarky comment to other people in their lists, then I suspect you SHOULD be able to take it as well in yours.

Cheers and have a good day. =)
Edit: 1 year, 8 months ago
Posted: 1 year, 8 months ago at Aug 31 23:15
Btw I also disagree about Calista Flockhart. I don't see the resemblance between her and Audrey Hepburn, not just physically but also emotionally. They may have similar facial features but I doubt Calista can ever able to capture the true essence and charisma of Audrey.

Regarding her acting skill, yes, she's a good actress but not great as in the calibre of Meryl Streep. And I'd rather choose an actress based on her ACTING SKILL/TALENTS first over her looks/beauty.

Again, cheers to you! =)
Edit: 1 year, 8 months ago
Posted: 1 year, 7 months ago at Oct 8 10:16
I disagree... she stutters all the time, always sounds confused, and sadly she only does movies now where she takes her clothes off. Now she's taken the role of Catwoman from the hundreds of talented, gorgeous women who would've actually suited it so well D; D; D;

but thanks =D
Posted: 1 year, 2 months ago at Feb 27 20:02
Calista is a very underrated actress. Then again, it would be hard for even the best modern actor to pull of a Hollywood legend like Audrey. I do think Calista would do her justice. I do believe though that no one can play Judy Garland, her emotional depth and vulnerability can't be acted out. If one person tried, it should be Hilary Swank. Great list!!
Posted: 1 year, 2 months ago at Mar 12 13:57
I agree with everything you said... For Judy, I can't really name anyone could have her presence, so I just tried to pick people who looked like her and weren't bad actors. and thanks!
Posted: 5 months, 2 weeks ago at Dec 5 3:54
How about these?

Steve Buscemi as Peter Lorre


NATHAN LANE as LOU COSTELLO


HALLE BERRY as LENA HORNE
Berry has already played famous actresses like Dorothy Dandridge (1922-1965), but of all of the great black actresses out there I think only Berry could play legendary singer Lena Horne (1917-2010). When Horne was alive it was proposed that Janet Jackson would play her life, but Horne was against it. Berry of course can not sing, but she can act.

CHRIS ROCK as RICHARD PRYOR
Now I know this is stretching it a bit, but I always thought Chris Rock has more acting chops than his movies have shown. He is a great comedian, and I believe he can capture the essence of fellow funny man Richard Pryor (1940-2005). Pryor's life could make a trilogy of movies not just one film, but again Chris Rock is not yet viewed as a capable dramatic actor.

KELSEY GRAMMER AS JACK BENNY
I am a big fan of both Kelsey Grammer and Jack Benny (1894-1974), and it is amazing at the similarities in the comic styles of both actors. Looking at Grammer on the television series "Cheers" and "Frasier", you see a lot of Jack Benny in Grammer's mannerisms. Grammer even hosted a great special on Benny for NBC in 1995. I am not sure of Kelsey Grammer looks enough like Jack Benny, but I think it would be a great role to do. Unfortunately, Jack Benny was such a nice guy, it would probably be boring doing his life story.


For every great film movie like Jamie Foxx as Ray Charles in Ray (2004), there is Faye Dunaway as Joan Crawford in Mommie Dearest (1981). Still Hollywood will continue to make film biographies because where else but Hollywood could the town get the best ideas and stories. The stars' lives are often more interesting than the movies they were in.

Posted: 4 months, 2 weeks ago at Jan 10 15:57
HAHA, Steve is dead on! the others are good too.

Login or Signup to post a comment