"When:: 2004 (about a week before my 13th birthday)
This barely makes it on here because of the age limit on the list, but it does just get in. I watched Vertical Limit, thought Malcolm was hot as hell and proceeded to obsess for a while. This caused me to rent Sample People a few months later, but I ended up with a crush on Nathan Page instead. Of course, he was barely in anything back then and now he's getting all the damn roles.